Delaware County (OH) Board of Commissioners · 2026-06-04

Transcript

Delaware County Commissioners' Session- June 4, 2026

730 segments

June 4th, 2026 meeting of the Delaware

County Board of Commissioners. Would you

please rise and join me in the pledge

to the flag of the United States of

America and to the republic for which it

stands, one nation under God,

indivisible, with liberty and justice

for all.

>> Okay. Thank you. Um I'm Jeff Benton,

president of the board this year. Um,

fellow commissioner and vice president

Gary Merrell is not here today, but

fellow commissioner Barb Lewis is is is

joining us. Our administrator is Tracy

Davies. Our deputy administrator and

council is Eric Hostetler. And I know I

saw Don. Oh, there's Don. Our other ad

uh assistant administrator is is here as

well. Don Houston, Alli Glucich, and

Jennifer Walraven are going to run the

meeting. Resolution number 26-378

in the matter of approving the

electronic record of proceedings from

regular meeting held June 1st 2026.

>> So move

>> second discussion vote

>> vote on motion 26-378.

Mrs. Lewis

>> I.

>> Mr. Benton

>> I.

>> We do have public comment signed up for

today but we're going to address that

during the item number eight. So that

brings us to item number three,

resolution number 26-379

in the matter of approving purchase

orders that announce certificates

amendments of Warrington batch number

CMBBR0601.

>> So move

>> second discussion vote

>> vote on motion 26-379.

Mrs. Lewis

>> I.

>> Mr. Bettton

>> I. Resolution number 26-380

in the matter of acknowledging receipt

of annexation petition from agent for

the petitioner Laura McGregor Comacquire

requesting annexation of 43.362

acres of land in Delaware township to

the city of Delaware

>> so move

>> second discussion

>> vote

>> vote on motion 26-380 Mrs. Lewis

>> I

>> Mr. Benton.

>> Hi.

>> Resolution number 26-381

in the matter acknowledging receipt of

annexation petition from agent for the

petitioner Laura McGregor Comquire

requesting annexation of 58.558

acres of land in Delaware Township to

the city of Delaware.

>> So move

>> second discussion vote.

>> Vote on motion 26-381. Mrs. Lewis

>> I.

>> Mr. Benton

>> I. Resolution number 26-382

in the matter of declaring personal

property obsolete, unfit or not needed

for public use and authorizing the sale

of such property via internet auction or

the disposal of property at no value.

>> So move second. Finally, some

discussion.

>> Good morning. John Melvin, director of

facilities. Yeah, the attached list of

vehicles have been removed from service

and been replaced with new vehicles and

ready for internet auction.

>> Okay. Any questions or comments?

>> No. My only comment would be three of

them have pretty low mileage considering

how old they are. The other 10 to 13

years old. Um so I would just encourage

>> Yeah. The uh the one pickup truck was a

maintenance vehicle who got driven a lot

of short mileage around town. So not a

lot of you know trips on it, but a lot

of trips but not a lot of miles put on.

>> Okay. Well, again, just keeping an eye

on the number of vehicles if we don't

put a lot of miles on that we ought to

try to combine

>> and and reduce the fleet.

>> Yep.

>> Um, vote, please. Jennifer,

>> vote on motion 26-382. Mr. Benton,

>> I.

>> Mrs. Lewis,

>> I.

>> Resolution number 26-383

in the matter of approving a cash lease

with Dawson Farms Incorporated for a

county farmland located at Vixby Parkway

and Botown Road.

>> So, move.

>> Second. Discussion. Uh this is the

farmland uh recently acquired uh by the

county. Dawson Farms owns the field

adjacent to this and has been farming

both parcels. Um so uh to keep that

ground in farmland for the current being

Eric helped negotiate lease with Dawson

Farms so that he can farm it this year.

>> Okay.

>> Any questions, comments? Vote, please.

>> Vote on motion 26-383.

Mrs. Lewis,

>> I.

>> Mr. Benton,

>> I.

>> Thank you. Item number eight is an

administrator for review of the

conditions stated in section 709.023E

of the revised code for annexation

petition from agent for the petitioner

Elizabeth Cedorfu requesting annexation

of 175 acres of land in Troy Township to

the city of Delaware. And this is the

item that we did have some people sign

up for public comment for.

>> Okay. So move.

>> Well, it's not a resolution.

>> Oh, it's not.

>> You have to do the review.

>> We don't want to do that. Okay.

>> Um I Eric, I should just go through the

script.

>> Okay. I'll just go through the script

for our review. And again, it's

important to understand this is a

review, not a hearing. Um and so I'll

just kind of go through real quick.

Pursuant to section 709.023E 023E

of the revised code. If an objection to

an expedited type 2 annexation petition

is timely filed with the board of county

commissioners, the board shall review

the petition to determine if if each of

the following conditions has been met.

One, the petition meets all the

requirements set forth in and was filed

in the manner provided in section

709.021 of the revised code. Two, the

persons who signed the petition are

owners of the real estate located

located in the territory proposed for

annexation and constitute all of the

owners of real estate in that territory.

Three, the territory proposed for

annexation does not exceed 500 acres.

Four, the territory proposed for

annexation shares a continuous boundary

with the municipal corporation to which

annexation is proposed for continuous

length of at least 5% of the perimeter

of the territory proposed for

annexation. Five, the annexation will

not create an unincorporated area of the

township that is completely surrounded

by the territory proposed for

annexation. Six, the municipal

corporation to which annexation is

proposed has agreed to provide to the

territory proposed for annexation the

services specified in the relevant

ordinance or resolution adopted under

division C of this section. Seven. If a

street or highway will be divided or

segmented by the boundary line between

the township and the municipal

corporation is to create a road

maintenance problem, the municipal

corporation to which annexation is

proposed has agreed as a condition of

the annexation to assume the maintenance

of that street or highway or to

otherwise correct the problem as used in

this section. Street or highway has the

same meaning as in section 4511.01

of the revised code. And so again, this

process is an administrative review, not

a public hearing. Therefore, no

testimony will be taken and no evidence

will be presented. However, interested

parties were advised of the date of this

review and were given the opportunity to

submit any additional comments in

writing and or appear at this meeting to

provide public comments, which we will

begin here in a moment. The review is

limited to the conditions stated in

section 709.023E 023E of the revised

code and the board's determination of

whether all conditions have been met

will be based on review of the petition

as submitted along with other documents

submitted in accordance with section

7090.023

including municipal corporation services

resolution or ordinance and the

resolutions or ordinances stating

objections to the proposed annexation.

So, at this point, I will turn it over

to our council, who is much more of an

expert on this this topic than I am,

kind of walk us through the next where

we're headed with this.

>> Uh, thank you, Eric Hostetler. Um, if if

if it's okay with the board, we can just

kind of go through the the factors um

and I can provide information on the

staff level review of the petition and

all of the documents that have been

submitted. So number one, the petition

meets all the requirements set forth in

and was filed in the manner provided in

section 709.021 of the revised code. Um

this sets the basic parameters for the

petition, the contents of the petition

and the manner in which it was filed. Um

staff review noted no um problems with

that condition. Um it was signed by all

of the owners. Um, one thing I would

mention is that uh there appear to be uh

some railroad property and maybe some

utility property within the area, but

those are not defined as owners in the

statute. So, they didn't need to sign

the petition. Um, the uh they're

required to have an accurate uh

description and a map um of the area to

be annexed. Those were reviewed by the

engineers map department. So, we don't

have any concerns with those conditions.

Um, and it was filed with the the clerk

as dictated by statute. So, staff didn't

note any concerns with that condition

number one.

Uh, number two, the persons who signed

the petition are owners of the real

estate located in the territory proposed

for annexation and constitute all of the

owners of real estate in that territory.

And I just covered that. Uh, appears to

be signatures of all of the owners. um

any property that's within the area to

be annexed that did not sign the

petition u would appear to be right

ofway or if fee held it's still right of

way for railroad or utility purposes so

they didn't need to sign

um it also includes some road rightway

and also public entities that uh own

right of way are not required to sign

petition either.

Uh number three, the territory proposed

for annexation does not exceed 500

acres. Um the map as approved by

reviewed and approved by the engineers

office indicates that the acreage is 175

acres. So no concerns with that

condition.

The number four, the territory proposed

for annexation shares a contiguous

boundary with the municipal corporation

to which annexation is proposed for

continuous length of at least 5% of the

perimeter of the territory proposed for

annexation. Um that is another condition

that is reviewed by the engineers map

department. Um so we did not note any

concerns with that based on the map that

was reviewed and approved.

Uh number five, the annexation will not

create an unincorporated area of the

township that is completely surrounded

by the territory proposed for

annexation. Um no islands um appear

within the map that was reviewed and

approved. So no staff level concerns

with number five. Uh number six, that is

the basis of the township's objection.

So staff reviewed the township's

objection, reviewed the services

resolution that the city of Delaware uh

had adopted and submitted.

Um and the I I want to point out that

the language of the provision states the

municipal corporation to which

annexation is proposed has agreed to

provide to the territory proposed for

annexation the services specified in the

relevant ordinance or resolution adopted

under division C of this section. And

this is a provision that has been

reviewed judicially um was in the second

district court of appeals. And

um I'll just read briefly from that

case. Uh and this is uh out of involving

the Miami County Board of County

Commissioners. Um the statute plainly

states that a municipal corporation must

agree to provide what services, if any,

are specified in the relevant ordinance

or resolution to the territory proposed

for annexation. In other words, the

resolution may specify that a

municipality will provide all, some or

perhaps none of its services to the

annexed territory. If the mis if the

municipality has approved a services

resolution under RC 709.023C,

the condition in 709.023E6

is satisfied. So staff's recommendation

to the board is that the objection is

not well founded because services

resolution was submitted. Um any dispute

about the date on which sewer would be

provided is irrelevant to meeting this

condition as far as the board's review

of this condition goes. So that's the

staff's recommendation on number six.

>> Okay. Eric, if I could just stop you

there. So what you're saying is this the

statute does not require a date to be

specified.

>> So the statute that that requires the

services resolution mentions a date and

that's what was referenced in the um

objection is that hey there's not a

there's not a date related to sewer and

so essentially they're not really

committing to provide it by any

particular date. Um, however, the

condition that you're required to review

does not mention a date. And the court's

interpretation of that in at least in

the second district, and I agree with

it, is that as long as the services

resolution states what services they're

going to provide, first off, they don't

need to provide any. So even if we say

they have not agreed to provide sewer by

any certain date, they don't need to

provide sewer. They need to provide the

services that they've said that they

would. Um, and so since that resolution

was submitted to the board and in the

time required in the statute, I don't

see any basis for the objection.

>> Okay.

>> Uh, number seven, uh, I'm not going to

read that one because it's too long. Um,

but this this deals with the

segmentation or division of roadways and

this this was a an issue that we've

identified in previous annexations. Um,

our request to municipal corporations is

to include this language in their

services resolution. Um, some

municipalities have done that. Sunbury,

for example, has done that. Um, I think

there's been an annexation in Powell

where they've done that. The services

resolution that the city of Delaware

adopted just mentions road maintenance

and said that it'll be road maintenance

will be provided um upon annexation. Um,

but it doesn't specifically address

segmentation or division of the roads.

Um in this annexation, Hills Miller Road

would be divided down the middle because

the um annexation goes to the center

line. Same for Troy Road. So, Hills

Miller Road is a township road. Um Troy

Road is a county road. So, the board

could determine that that segmentation

or division would create a road

maintenance problem. And so the statute

requires that the city um either agree

as a condition of the annexation to

assume the maintenance of that street or

highway or to otherwise correct the

problem. And again um I I go to this is

actually Supreme Court case and we've

talked about this in prior uh prior

reviews. It's state Xelzena versus the

Green County Board of Commissioners and

they uh provided some additional uh

context for this. Um so RC 709.023E7

the condition we're reviewing right now

provides that a municipal corporation

must agree either to assume the

maintenance of the street or highway or

the emphasis is in the case to otherwise

correct the problem in light of the

clause's disjunctive phrasing. It does

not matter whether the attorney's

statement under undermined the city's

promise to assume street maintenance

duties because the city had agreed to

quote otherwise correct the problem. So

the city had provided a letter came

yesterday from the city manager uh

providing some clarification on what

their obligation was as they see it

under their services resolution and

essentially it it includes that language

that I just read. So any statement that

creates some doubt as to whether the

city will or has agreed to otherwise

correct the problem. Um I I don't think

that we have any basis to deny the

petition based on that ambiguity. Um I

would just point out that the letter um

references that the township would still

maintain portions of the roadway that

are outside of the annexed territory.

Um, and there's a factual inaccuracy in

that letter in that one of the roads in

question is a county road. So, it would

actually be the county that would be

trying to resolve any road maintenance

problems for Troy Road. It would be the

township that would be trying to resolve

any road maintenance problems for

Hillsmiller Road. Um, but staff's

recommendation is that the the condition

has been met. um particularly

particularly because of the

clarification the city provided that

they've they've agreed that they will

correct the problem uh rel related to

any creation of a road maintenance

problem. So that's a summary of the

staff level review of the petition and

the objection and all of the

information's been submitted and your

recommendation is that you grant the

petition. Good.

Thank you, Eric, for all that work.

Any comments?

>> Um, no.

>> Okay. Um, so we should go ahead with

public comment then. We'll do that next.

Um,

>> the is it do you start with for or

against? Does it make any difference?

>> Um, I mean, I guess those here to speak

about in favor of granting the petition

should go first.

>> Okay, that's the direction we'll go. Um

those uh we have three

uh people who registered for public

comment um in favor of the granting of

petition. So I will uh ask uh Mr. Shade

who's number number one on the on the

list

if you could uh identify yourself.

>> Yes.

>> We're recording this.

>> Good morning. My name is Michael Shade.

I'm an attorney at law, 236 West Central

Avenue, Delaware, Ohio. And I represent

the uh Paul Phyllis Price, their

respective trust, who are the owners of

all the land um on previous annexations

and on this annexation, and they are

they have made the decision that they

are supporting this. They also own land

north. That land was not included. is

not going to be annexed and it at the

present time it's not going to be

annexed and it's not before you today

and it's staying in the township. So, uh

it was just it was strictly a decision

of the family and the uh owners and they

deliberated on this extensively over

several years and and they they believe

that this is in the best interest of

their family and and they're since that

time uh Paul Price died. Uh Paul Price,

if anybody was committed to townships,

he was a township trustee at Troy

Township for an extensive period of time

and um and the their current residence

is staying in the township. Um that was

a a matter of personal choice. They were

also graduates of of the predecessors to

Buckeye Valley School District and they

believe in that school district. So

everything that's in this annexation

will be serviced by Buckeye Valley

Schools. Everything below it will be

serviced by Delaware City Schools. I

didn't make the rules. That's all we

have. Thank you.

>> All right. Thank you, Mr. Shade. Um,

next is uh Jill Tangan. I say that

right?

>> Okay.

Welcome again. If you could identify

yourself.

>> Thank you. Uh Jill Tangaman. I'm an

attorney with Vory Seders Seymour and

Peas. I'm here with Beth Seedorf who is

the petitioner uh agent for the

petitioner. Uh we're here uh in support

of of the petition that we filed. Um I

think thank you to Eric for spending all

that extra time looking at the the

requirements. We made every effort to

make sure that all of the requirements

were met uh and that you had all the

information you needed in front of you.

We'll be happy to answer any questions

that we have. Uh we do think this is a

benefit to the community. It'll provide

utilities, a school site, and a lot of

other um amenities for this area over a

longer period of time and allow for a

master plan um for cohesive development.

So, we appreciate your time. Thank you.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you.

>> All right. One more speaker in favor of

granting the petition. That's uh Oh,

man. Bill

How do you spell

>> Keeler?

>> Keeler. Okay. I Yeah, it looks like

Hyra.

>> I've got pretty bad handwriting, so I

apologize for that.

>> Go right ahead. You got to identify

yourself and pardon me.

>> If you could identify yourself, we're

recording.

>> Bill Keith, 5131 Post Road. Uh I am the

uh developer of the property and um just

here to answer any questions if you have

any. but um not relevant, but I've also

sat down with Buckeye Valley School.

That's the first thing we do and they

are in support of everything we're

doing. I've actually talked about it

putting an elementary school on the

site. We're still working through that

along with the Delaware City Schools of

potential high schools. So, we're really

excited with the uh development and

working with the municipalities. and we

go in with a kind of a win-winwin

approach and it has to win for the

community. Um the school district

obviously the the children are the most

important and we got to make some money

along the way too. So we're excited

about the project and I'll answer any

questions that you have from me. Thank

you.

>> Okay. Thank you. That's it for the

public comments in favor of the granting

the petition.

And so I will turn it over to

uh we have one person signed up u to

speak in opposition to granting the pet

the petition that is Mr. Doug Price

and uh

welcome

Doug Price. I'm here on behalf of the

Troy Township Trustees. Um

I kind of disagree with Eric's comment.

Um in

709.023

E6 it says

that there has to be an approximate date

when the services will be provided.

The city and corridor development have a

pre-anexation agreement

that does not have a commitment or a

time frame to provide sewer. Even though

the city says it will provide sewer,

there is no time frame to provide sewer

down the road. So that is the basis of

our

objection to the annexation. It has

nothing to do with the petitioners or

anything. It is the city cannot provide

sewer service to the area. They have to

build a new trunk line if millions of

dollars. Do they have the ability in the

near future? That is the big basis of

our objection. Plus, under E7 of 709,

the maintenance, the city says that they

will take over the maintenance. We got

this agreement last night after 5:00. We

haven't even had time to study it in the

agreement.

They are asking the township if we want

to do a shared services agreement. We

got this at 5:00 last night. They've had

it since May. Why did they wait till

5:00 last night to give it to us before

the meeting today?

We haven't had time to study it, look at

it. They've never come to us, approached

us on any of it.

They are also looking to extend Hal Road

up to Hills Miller Road, which is a

township road.

Alk roads, a five-lane road to dump

volumes of traffic onto a township road

is not a feasible

in our opinion that you know what burden

would that put on a township to

you know we would have to expand Hills

Miller Road that we do not have the

ability the funds to do without going

for OPWC money that we may or may not

So, those are our comments and why we're

asking to deny the petition right now.

>> Very good. Thank you.

>> Uh, okay. That's it for speakers uh

public comment in favor or opposition to

granting the petition.

So,

open it up for comments. Any further

comment,

Derek? Commissioner Lewis?

>> Well, it's um pardon me. Um expedited

type two annexation petition. And as our

council said, we're obligated to to uh

um follow

uh what is set forth and

not sure why they got it the info uh to

you so late, the city that is, but I

mean under what we have to do, it's it

seems clear to me that we need to just

approve it.

Yeah, that's where I am as well. Um,

again, our council is very experienced

in these and provides good insights, has

done a lot of research on it,

>> and therefore I would support that as

well that we need to go ahead and grant

it. Um,

so

with that, I would ask the clerk to read

the motion to grant the annexation,

please. Resolution number 26-384

in the matter of granting the annexation

petition of 175 acres of land in Troy

Township to the city of Delaware.

>> So moved.

>> Second. Any further discussion? Uh vote

please.

>> Vote on motion 26-384.

Mrs. Lewis

>> I.

>> Mr. B.

>> I.

>> That brings us to item number nine.

Administrative reports.

>> Nothing for me today. Thank you.

>> Nothing. Don, anything?

Okay. Um, Mr. Lewis,

>> I don't have anything.

>> All right. Well, I got a couple things.

Um, went to the high school number five

groundbreaking um in uh on Bunny Station

Road T Monday or Tuesday, whatever.

Monday. And it is phenomenal that uh

Tangi's is looking at a fifth high

school, which is their 29th building.

They have 139 acres uh there to build

that high school as well as an

elementary school on that site. Um just

a lot of excitement about it. Uh it's a

big project. It'll open in August of 28.

So it's a little over two years to to

build it. So congratulations to Oklahoma

or Oklahoma

uh to well and to Angie for the for the

the successful groundbreaking of that

fifth high school. Incredible the the

growth they have. Um, Morpsy executive

committees this afternoon. The memorial

tournament continues. It had they have

teed off. So if you haven't started

recording, Jennifer, you can start.

>> Well, I better leave.

>> It doesn't actually it doesn't start

till 2 o'clock.

>> The golf channel at 2 o'clock.

>> Okay.

>> You can run home run for lunch and then

do that.

>> And then lastly, I went to the Blackwing

uh Blackwing had a a ribbon cutting this

morning. uh the the u the gun gun uh

organization company on the west side of

town actually not in the town but west

of town and they've renovated and had

expanded. They're just doing great and

Rex Gore and his son Mark is now running

it and it was just a really nice event

very well attended. So, congratulations

to Rex and Mark and the family on the

the renovation of this very good

community-minded organization. So, um

nothing for executive session today. So

with