City of Columbus City Council · 2026-05-19

Transcript

Columbus City Council Meeting

5872 segments

Committee number 25 and I'll come to

order. Please stand for the playing of

the national anthem.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Pres, would you lead us in the pledge?

>> I pledge algiance to the flag of the

United States of America and to the

republic for which it stands, one nation

under God, indivisible, with liberty and

justice for all.

>> This evening, council is grateful to

have minister Jordan uh Peaks of Garden

City Church here to pray with us.

Jordan, welcome back to council.

Praise the Lord everybody.

Matthew 6:33 says to seek first the

kingdom of God and all of his

righteousness and all of these things

shall be added unto us. And so God, I

just thank you for this day. God, I

thank you for waking us up in our right

minds and for choosing to renew right

spirits within us. God, I thank you for

every individual under the sound of my

voice. For every bloodline, every

storyline, every testimony that's

represented here in this room. I pray,

Lord God, that these leaders would truly

be those who seek your face above every

other thing, Lord, and that they would

truly lead from the posture of intimacy

and overflow with you. I pray

specifically on this day, Lord God, that

this meeting would go well. I pray, Lord

God, that your grace would abound here,

that your mercy would abound here in the

name of Jesus. I pray Lord God that your

peace would permeate God the streets of

Columbus. And I pray Lord God that as

these leaders continue to lead this city

well. That they would look to you Jesus

for all wisdom, all strategy, all

guidance in the name of Jesus. I pray

Lord God that it would be their joy to

serve your people. That it would be

their joy to serve you. And I just pray

Holy Spirit that you would allow a a

boldness to come about these leaders.

Lord God, I pray for President Harden

and God and all of their team that you

would guard their hearts and their minds

that you would allow it to truly be

their delight to serve. And I thank you,

Lord Jesus, that beyond any title that

they hold or anything that you do, that

they would first be sons and daughters

of the one true living God. And so

Jesus, we just thank you not just for

what you've done or what you will do,

but here on this Monday evening, we just

take a moment to say, Jesus, we thank

you for who you are. We thank you that

you're patient, that you're kind, that

you're loving toward us, that you're

gracious, and that you're merciful. And

we just pray Jesus have your way in this

meeting. In your name we pray. Amen.

>> Amen. Thank you, pastor. Clerk, please

call the role.

>> Bankston Barrosa de Padilla, Dorne,

Remy, Ross, Vice President Harden. Any

person who takes any action to obstruct

or interfere with the conduct of

tonight's meeting may be charged with

disturbing a lawful meeting pursuant to

Columbus City Code 2317.12.

Any person who enters those areas of

city council chambers reserved for city

officials or invited guests may be

charged with criminal trespass pursuant

to Columbus city code 2311.21.

>> Can I get a motion to dispense with the

reading of the journal?

>> Clerk, please call the row. Banks Rosa

de Padilla Dors Remy Ross Vice President

Harden.

>> There is one correction to the May 11th

journal referenced by the city clerk.

Zoning ordinances 0290-2026,

Ordinance 0291-2026,

Ordinance 1035-2026

and Ordinance 1036-20

20226 inadvertently appeared as first

read items on the May 11, 2020 26

agenda. However, they had a first

reading on April 20th 2026. If there are

no other additions or corrections to the

journal, the journal is approved. This

week's communication received by the

city clerk's office are listed on the

agenda and will be published in city

bulletin. Are there any other

communications related to the record?

>> Not at this time.

>> We'll go around the dis for uh

resolutions and updates from my

colleagues starting with council

bankster.

>> Council member Rosa de Padilla.

>> Thank you, Council President. Um so

first I would like to start off by

saying happy bike month everyone. I want

to thank folks who took the opportunity

last week to bike to work. Um and this

is first of all every month should be

bike month but especially this month we

encourage residents to get out to get on

our biking trails to get in our

protected bike lanes with your friends

with your family. Bike to that

restaurant bike to work. Bike to all the

places that you enjoy going. But this

month is really a celebration about all

things biking. So, happy bike month

everyone. Um, I also wanted to uh give a

friendly reminder to everyone that our

street parking changes have gone into

effect this month, this May. They went

into effect. Hopefully, you didn't

notice cuz hopefully you did not get a

ticket. But, um, I just want to

emphasize some of the changes that folks

will see. So, uh, we are introducing a

tiered payment plan. While some ticket

fees are increasing, residents who make

their payments within the first seven

days of receiving the ticket will

receive a $20 discount. So, if you don't

put it just in your purse or in your

glove compartment, make sure you pay for

it and you're going to pay a little bit

less than what the rate is. Among the

other changes, we're also introducing

safety mobility focus violations. So, if

you park in a bike lane, and I see you

friends on Broad Street that I travel

every day. Um, if you park in a bike

lane or a bus lane, you will be fined a

ticket. And it can cost up to $100 if

it's not paid within 30 days. And so,

this is also just another mark of making

sure that the mobility tools that we

have in the street, like bike lanes,

like bus lanes are kept for those

purposes. Um, we hope that this new

policy will continue ensuring the safety

on our streets and ensuring fair access

to on- street parking. We want to make

sure that there's high turnover and high

demand areas and commercial corridors so

people can get to where they need to go.

So, with that, director, is there a

specific place that folks can go to if

they wanted to see what the different

parking changes are? Is that on our

website?

>> You caught me off guard.

>> I know. Sorry. I'm I was gone a week and

I'm a little rusty.

>> Uh good evening, President Harden, uh

Chair Bose, the deputy of members of

council. It is on the website and um I

do not have that right now.

>> No, that's okay. If folks are

interested, if you want to see what

those differences are, we had a public

hearing about it, so folks can always go

to YouTube, but you can also check out

the city's website to see those uh

changes. But if everybody downloads the

park mobile app, then you can ensure

because it will tell you exactly where

you're parking and it'll give you

reminders so that you don't get those

parking tickets. So, happy parking

everyone and happy bike month. Thank

you.

>> Thank you, Council Member Preso. Tim,

Council Member Remy.

>> Thank you very much, Council President.

I did want to take a moment to recognize

that today marks the beginning of

National EMS Week, Emergency Medical

Services Week. Throughout this week, let

us take the time to think about the men

and women across this nation, especially

right here in Columbus, who are often

the very first to arrive when someone's

experiencing an emergency or needs help

most. 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365

days a year, our EMS professionals show

up ready to serve our residents with

skill, compassion, and professionalism.

Our city would not function without them

and our community is safer because of

the their dedication and sacrifice. We

will be formally recognizing our EMS

personnel later this week and I look

forward to sharing more about that rec

recognition on social media. Council

member Ros, I'm done. Thank you,

>> Council Member W.

>> Thank you, Council President. Just a

quick reminder that this Wednesday, May

20th, from 3:00 to 7:00 p.m., we'll be

at the Glenwood Community Center for our

next Wednesdays with White office hours.

Obviously, RSVPs are encouraged, but

walk-ins are also welcome to RSVP.

Please visit bit.ly/w

Wednesdays with white or email my aid,

Chelsea Goldzman cler

mc columbus.gov. Um, hope to see

everyone there. That's it for me. Thank

you, council member. Um, my only uh

announcement is uh next week we do not

have council because uh as we observe

Memorial Day, but the following Monday

uh June 1st, we will host our annual

Pride illumination and Steven

Schullerberger award ceremony uh outside

of city council at 7:45 p.m. So, we

encourage and invite all the community

to come and participate. Uh looking to

my right, I also want to uh recognize

and welcome our new auditor. I think

it's her first time uh sitting uh here.

Welcome uh from Auditor Lewis. Welcome

to council. Um

are there any other comments from

elected officials, from the city's

office, from the treasur's office? Are

there any requests by members of council

for the removal of any ordinance uh on

or resolution or consent action tonight?

Hearing none, may we now have a motion

to wave the reading of titles of 30

legislation.

>> So moved. Second clerk, please call the

role.

>> Banks, Perosa, Deodia, Dorren, Remy,

Ross, Swiss, President Harden.

>> Thank you. Thank you. Will the clerk now

reading to the record the ordinance

number on 38 legislation tonight for

first reading?

>> In Finance and Governance Committee, we

have resolution 127X-2026,

ordinances 867 and 1379-2026,

Economic Development and Small and

Minority Business Committee ordinance

1306-2026.

Workforce Education and Labor Committee

Ordinance 1228, 1229, and 1230-2026.

Public Safety and Criminal Justice

Committee ordinances 1146 and 1329-2026.

Housing Homeless and Building Committee

ordinance 1383-2026.

Public Utilities and Sustainability

Committee, Ordinance 813, 1138, 1184,

1212, 1296, 1318, 1319, 1320,

1324, 1328, 1342, 1355, 1360, and

1362-2026.

>> Thank you, Madam Clerk. We don't have

any speakers on the first reading

portion of the agenda. The following

ordinance appear on our agenda as

consent. Will the clerk now read those

into the record? In Finance and

Governance Committee, we have ordinance

946, 1218, 1281, 1358, and 1388-2026.

Economic Development and Small and

Minority Business Committee. We have

resolution 122X-2026.

Ordinances 999, 1179, 1236, 1273, 1413,

and 1432-2026.

Neighborhoods, Recreation, and Parks

Committee. We have ordinance 666,

1068, 1069, 1074, 1076, 1077, 1083,

1092, and 1180-2026.

Workforce Education, Labor Committee,

Ordinance 1309, and 1376-2026.

Health, Human Services, and Equity

Committee, Ordinance 1226- I'm Yeah,

1226-2026.

Public Safety and Criminal Justice

Committee Ordinance 267 and 1307-2026.

Housing Homelessness and Building

Committee Ordinance 1012, 1298, 1303,

1321, 1341, 1344, 1363, 1364, and

1370-2026.

Public Utilities and Sustainability

Committee Ordinance 1025, 1125, 1149,

1222, 1240, 1247, 1256, 1278, 1322, and

1359-2026.

and rules and policy committee. We have

appointments A89, A91, A92, A93, A94,

A95, A96, A97, A98, A99, A100, A101,

A102, A103, A104, A105, A106, A107,

A108, and A109-2026.

>> Thank you, Madam Clerk. Again, we have

no speakers on the consent portion of

the agenda. Are there any questions or

concerns from my colleagues on consent

agenda? Hearing none. May I have a

motion to approval of these items?

>> So moved.

>> Second.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Thanks, Deborrosa, Deodia, Dorance,

Remy, Ross, Weiss, President Harden.

>> The consent portion of our agenda is

passed. We'll now proceed with the

second reading of 30-day postponed in

emergency legislation. The first

committee to come for council is the

finance and governance committee. That

committee is chaired by council member

Bankston. Council member, the floor is

yours.

>> Uh thank you, council president. And uh

tonight in the finance and governance

committee uh first we have ordinance

0881-2026

to authorize the director of department

of technology to enter into a contract

with crash soft technology corp for

VMware techn technical account manager

uh services software licensing to wave

the competitive bidding provisions of

Columbus City codes and to authorize the

expenditure of $18,21918

from the department of technology

information services division

information services operating fund.

This ordinance authorizes a contract

with crash soft technology corp for

services so for services software

licensing to support city use of various

VMwarebased platforms such as workspace

1 VMware hypervisor and NSX-T.

VMware software is the core component

that is needed to operate virtual

servers that run critical applications

for the city such as Excella, the

Columbus utility billing system and 311

just to name a few. The city receives

special pricing with Crashoft via the

Ohio Academic Resource Network. Uh so a

waiver of competitive bid is requested

to access that uh more competitive

pricing. Heard any questions or comments

from my colleagues? Seeing none, I move

for passage.

>> Bankston Barros Padia Dorren Remy Ross,

Vice President Harden.

>> Thank you, Council President. May I move

uh to the uh economic development and

small minority business committee.

>> Thank you. Uh we have in the uh economic

development small minority business

committee. First up is resolution

0121X-20226

to determine that the written uh consent

providing for the addition of certain

properties of the confluence community

authorities new community district and

its owned or controlled by the city of

Columbus, Ohio insufficient and complies

with the requirements of chapter 349 of

the Ohio Revised Code to set the time

and place for a public hearing on such

consent and to authorize the notice

notices. of such public hearing by

publication in a newspaper of general

circulation for three consecutive weeks

a or as provided in Ohio Revised Code

sections 7.16.

As a recap, this resolution confirms

receipt of a written notice from the de

from our department of development that

allows the scheduling and public notice

of a department of development held

hearing to discuss the addition of NWSL

deal parcels into the Confluence

Community Authority District. The

administrative step was originally

approved by the body via ordinance

1112-2026

and is an Ohio revised code requirement

since council serves as an

organizational board of commissioners

for the uh fluence community authority.

This resolution does not transfer the

parcels into the community authority. It

does not change the ownership of the

parcels and it does not legislate new

deal terms. Also, as was outlined last

week, no occupied residential parcels

are included in the proposal. At the

request of the McCoy Park Working Group,

tonight, council will move to amend this

resolution to remove parcels to the

north of the project site owned by

formerly owned by the Yonan family. with

us tonight to speak on the progress of

the work group and the legislation

timeline for the deal. We have uh our

chief of staff for the mayor Elon Sims

who is here with us um who will give us

just a really update on I think where we

are today progress of the uh work group

and to also maybe answer any additional

uh questions that my colleagues may

have. We do have one speaker on this as

well and we'll invite that speaker up

after Chief Sims. Chief

Well, good afternoon, Council President

Harden, Chair Banksson, and members of

council. Good to see you all uh this

afternoon. So, more than a year ago,

Mayor Gther announced his ambition for

Columbus to become the nation's capital

for girls and women's sports. Not just

for the opportunity to gain national

attention, but because sports helped

teach perseverance, teamwork,

leadership, and competence.

Those are skills that shape young people

well beyond the field of play. and into

school, business, community life. And as

a former D1 athlete myself, I can attest

to that that broader vision has included

our successful effort to secure a

national women's soccer league team for

Columbus, an opportunity that will have

both economic and community impact for

our city. I'm here to provide an update

on the on the work following council's

approval of ordinance 1112-2026

on April 20th. That ordinance authorized

the city to move forward with a

development agreement framework for the

proposed NWSL facilities project

including a training facility on the

city-owned land and involving McCoy Park

and adjacent city-owned parcels.

Importantly, the ordinance also

established several additional steps

related to expanded recreation

opportunities, additional parkland

evaluation, and continued public

engagement in Southwest Columbus.

This project represents a significant

opportunity for our city and it also

carries significant responsibilities for

to residents across Columbus to

neighbors in southwest Columbus to the

region or to excuse me to the original

vision connected to McCoy Park and to

the public process that is now underway.

Mayor Gther has been clear with our

team. Our responsibilities to the

southwest community must be taken

seriously, communicated clearly and

followed through fully. I also want to

address something directly tonight. We

understand that some residents have been

frustrated by this process and have

questions about the future of recreation

investments connected to McCoy Park. We

hear those concerns and we understand

why residents are asking those difficult

questions. This is why the

administration is approaching this work

with structure, accountability, and

continued public engagement. I also want

to acknowledge Liz Reed and other

community members who have been engaged

throughout this entire process. While

there may be have while there may have

been different perspectives on certain

components of this project, there's also

been a shared understanding that what we

must continue to do is working towards

solutions that serve both current

residents and the future generations of

here in Columbus. So tonight, I want to

provide an update on the working group

established through the ordinance

approved by council in April. This group

has now been meeting for several weeks

and includes discussions focused on

design concepts, site opportunities,

construction timelines, funding

strategies, and expanded recreation

opportunities tied to Southwest

Columbus. This group's work is focused

on ensuring that therapeutic recreation,

adaptive sports programming, and broader

park access opportunities remain central

to the path forward. These conversations

remain active and ongoing.

As many are aware, potential site

opportunities under review have already

been discussed publicly through media

reporting. Those concepts are expected

to be formally evaluated and

incorporated into the workg group's

final report and recommendations. A

draft outline for that report has

already been developed and the work

group will continue working towards

completion of the report within a

timeline established by council. It's

important to emphasize that no final

decisions have been made at this point

regarding the future park investments or

recreation opportunities connected to

this process. The group's charge is to

continue evaluating options that can

support recreation, park access, and

therapeutic programming for residents on

the southwest side. I also want to

clarify an important point that has

generated questions about the about the

within the community.

This ordinance approved by council in

Able did not finalize uh but yet outline

future components of this project. There

are still multiple legislative actions,

public hearings, funding considerations,

and agreement approvals that remain

ahead in this process. These steps

matter because they create continued

opportunities for both public input,

oversight, approval, and accountability

as this work moves forward. I also want

to address an important question

regarding the purpose of the amended

legislation being voted on tonight. The

administration proposed this amendment

to allow the city to move forward on

parallel paths. One track, on one track,

it allows the city to meet necessary

timelines associated with beginning site

work for the training facility. On a

second path, it allows important

conversations regarding the northern

McCoy uh parcels, future recreation

investments, and broader community uh

priorities in Southwest Columbus to

continue moving forward in a thoughtful

and deliberate way. From our

perspective, this approach allows us to

remain solution focused while continuing

meaningful engagement with residents,

council, and stakeholders regarding the

long-term vision for this area. At the

same time, we recognize that residents

want to see more than a process. They

want to see followrough. And that is why

this work is being approached with an

expectation that it results in tangible

recreation investments, expanded

opportunities, and meaningful long-term

benefit for Southwest Columbus

residents. As well as these

conversations continue, it is also

important that we do not reduce this

discussion to simply a conversation

about acreage. This must also be about a

conversation about access. access to

recreation, access to therapeutic

programming, access to amenities, and

greater access for all these things for

households across Southwest Columbus and

the entire city of Columbus.

Part of the work ahead is ensuring that

recreation activities are not

concentrated in just one location alone,

but that families across southwest side

have a meaningful opportunities to

connect multiple uh quality parks,

programming, and amenities closer to

where they live. This work is active and

moving forward. Consistent with Mayor

Ginther's commitment to open dialogue

and continued engagement with residents,

the mayor remains engaged in this

process and we continue to the

importance of delivering a real and

meaningful path forward for the people

of Southwest Columbus and the community

at large. We intend to provide

additional public updates as this work

advances in alignment with legislative

steps ahead. And you see those on the

screen here. Tonight, council will hear

the second reading of resolution

0121x2026.

This resolution establishes a date and

time for public hearing required by the

Ohio Vice Code and authorizes notice

process related to adding the identified

property to the Confluence Community

Authority District. The hearing is set

for 4:30 p.m. on June 24th at the

Michael B. Kman Center Gar parking

garage conference room. The

administration is also drafting

legislation related to administration

fee increase outlined in ordinance 1112

2026 and we anticipate bringing that

legislation to council in June. In

addition, the city's capital funding

contribution will require separate

legislation. We anticipate bringing that

ordinance forward following council

summer recess allowing in intentional

time for the work group to complete its

task in a thorough and responsible way.

At the same time, the administration

continues to work on agreements

authorized through ordinance 11126,

including the development, lease, and

contribution agreements.

We are also continuing conversations

with the Ynan family regarding the

naming of and use commitments connected

to the city's prior acquisition of those

parcels, including commitments

associated with therapeutic recreation

and adaptive sports programming. Dr.

Stevens and I and reps from the

ownership group uh met on just last

Friday. Excuse me. And those discussions

remain positive and and ongoing. In

closing, the commitments we made uh

matter. They have not been forgotten.

And we understand that residents will

ultimately measure this process not by

statements but but by followrough. So my

message is straightforward. This work

must continue moving forward with

purpose, structure, accountability, and

continue public engagement because

residents believe and deserve nothing

less. We understand that people hold

strong views about this project and we

respect those perspectives. We also

understand that projects of this scale

require steady and direct communication.

That's what the mayor expects. That's

what residents expects and that's how

this administration intends to proceed

moving forward. We will continue working

with each of you all uh the residents

and community stakeholders to move this

process forward responsibly,

transparently, and thoughtfully. With

that, myself and Director Stevens are

happy to answer any questions that you

all have.

Uh thank you uh Chief Sims. Are there

any questions from my colleagues?

Uh Council Member Broady.

>> So um Chief Sims, first of all, thank

you for that and thank you for the

thoroughess of walking us through. Um

can you talk just a little bit more

about that that parcel that we're

removing and why? just in case there are

folks who might be tuning in, might not

have followed along or understand what

the intention of that use of that land

is and what might the intention be

moving forward.

>> Yeah, I'll jump in here and director

Stevens, I'll have you jump in as well.

you know, as we've been having

conversations with the work group, part

of our the charge from this council has

really been worked to identify uh

southwest park opportunities and knowing

that um that that northern part of the

property is something that was part of

our consideration, we wanted to make

sure that um while the conversations

were ongoing about the facility of

itself that we could set aside time to

specifically get that work done, but

also focus our conversations

intentionally on what can happen on the

north side of that property. And so as

we had conversations with the ownership

group, community stakeholders,

administration, and council, we wanted

to make sure that we had more time to

address those concerns while also moving

the process forward on the training

facility and of itself.

>> And it is the intention to find an

additional property. Correct.

>> That is correct. And so as reported uh

this morning in the dispatch and what

you might have saw already, there's

opportunities around Green Leaf Park

that have been we're looking into. uh

the design concepts have been proposed

to the work group and as I shared

earlier we'll continue to assess other

additional opportunities but also

include that option in the final report

to you all uh as well.

>> Thank you. Any other questions from my

colleagues?

>> Thank you again for uh being here chief.

I think um I want to kind of reiterate

some of the comments I said last week

which is that in any economic

development deal of this scale there are

always going to be uh complications.

they're never straightforward. I think

in this particular deal, there are many

things along the pathway that uh the

last ordinance 1112 initiated and I

think that there was an assumption that

uh we were just moving through as

procedurally and so I think that folks

uh in the community I hope they see the

commitment that council has been doing

behind the scenes with working with the

work group as well as the administration

to say that we need to overcommunicate.

this is not a simple uh economic

development deal that we've seen in the

past and that we want to make sure that

we get it right. So I thank you and uh

for being here this evening and also

thank uh the work group that is working

diligently behind the scenes is made up

of both uh residents as well as uh

community leaders and the ownership

group. So again, thank you for being

here.

>> Y thank you.

>> Uh we do have one speaker in favor of

this tonight. So I'm going to ask Miss

Liz Reed uh to come up. Chair of the

Southwest Area Commission

and welcome back to Council Miss Reed. I

don't think I need to tell you the the

spill here. I think you got it. So, I'll

turn the floor over to you.

>> Uh, President Pardon, members of

council,

thank you for your continued efforts to

listen to the concerns of the community.

Quite a bit has changed since last week

in the working since last week in the

working group for ordinance 11126.

Uh first

first so first in last week's meeting it

was the owners group who first

recommended removing the green lawn

parcels from the amendment. Um I felt

that felt good that they were the ones

who proposed that first. Um

this reserves our ability to have future

conversations regarding these parcels.

However, these discussions have not

taken place yet.

with the passage of two items on today's

agenda 0121X

and -2026

I'm sorry and uh 1407-2026

there will be two small steps forward

one for the NWSL team and one towards

the fulfillment for what was envisioned

for McCoy Park

the working group still needs to find

many solutions to fulfill everything

that was envisioned for McCoy Park. We

have 42 days left of our 60.

We still need to find solutions for the

adaptive therapeutic park, the splash

pad, a garden,

comm community, a community center

building, 20 to 30 acres of parkland

loss, public accessibility

um to a park near McCoy Park,

a solution for the flooding that became

a feature in McCoy Park.

We still need timelines and we still

need funding.

These discussions last week

in last week's meeting were more

promising, but there's still a lot of

work to do. I appreciate Elon Sims

providing timelines for the NWSL tonight

to ensure that there will be no

surprises as we move forward.

However, we don't have clear timelines

on the community parks or park or parks.

With the green lawn parcels available

for discussion, the community feels

cautiously optimistic about fulfilling

what was envisioned for McCoy Park.

Resolution 0121X-2026

allows for public a public hearing and

does not automatically move McCoy Park

into the NCA.

During the group meeting, the city

representatives assured us that the

hearing is more than a legal

requirement,

that the community comments will be

considered.

Although the date has not been set for

the community meeting regarding

fulfilling what was uh envisioned for

McCoy Park,

that should occur before the June 24th

date for the MCA hearing.

So I do want to note that this

resolution also states that exhibit B

attached here too to conform to the

additional property to phase one of the

new training facility site subject to fi

it's subject to final design and

operational requirements. So, I just

want to be cautious around those terms

so that when we do see what that final

thing looks like that it's not

encroaching um or going into those uh

green lawn parcels. So, we're concerned

about that, but with the public hearing

and also knowing that you're going to

listen to that feedback. Um I understand

from today's uh presentation that the

first reading will be the week before

we'll have the hearing and then during

the second read um if there are concerns

um our community will be here to to

inform you of those concerns.

I know my time is up, so I I guess my

question is I do have some discussion um

about a resolution or I'm sorry about an

ordinance that's later on the agenda. Um

do you mind if I go ahead and talk about

that now um because it does relate to

this in some regard?

>> Okay, I appreciate that. Thank you. Um,

so regarding ordinance 1407-2026,

the Southwest Area Commission identified

a parcel of land that came for sale

three about three years ago and the

Columbus Recreation and Parks Department

purchased that land. It's about 9 acres

um and it is central to the Southwest

Area Commission

um near residential areas without a

park. Um so the Department of Recreation

and Parks um did they did purchase that

property and we did as of today as of

before these amendments and these um

ordinances we didn't have any plans for

development of those parks. So with

today's um legislation on 1407-2026,

those parcels

um it essentially moves design money

from the McCoy Park design phase 2 to be

able to do parcels or design work for

this parcel, the green leaf parcel, as

well as potentially other parcels that

are identified. It also allows for

additional funds to be added to that so

that we can start working on this

quickly.

The community, as I mentioned earlier,

we are cautiously optimistic. The tenor

of the working group changed quite a

bit. Um the owners group, council

representatives and recreation and parks

are all voicing efforts towards

achieving the goals of this working

group. It would be lovely to see a quick

coordinated efforts to fulfill what was

envisioned for McCoy Park within the

stated timelines and at the same time

the NWSL training facility is built.

The community's replacements

are also to ensure that at the same time

the community replacements are moving

forward in in those same timelines. Um,

so what we're happy about is that we're

going to have two pieces of legislation

before you today. That is one step

forward for the NWSL and one step

forward for the community. So we're we

we appreciate that and we're hoping we

continue to see those kind of combined

efforts.

>> Thank Thank you, Miss Reed, and thank

you for uh your contin advocacy and

leadership uh throughout this. Any

questions uh for Chairwoman Reed? Uh,

Council Member Bosa, date the deal.

>> Um, I first wanted to say thank you. I I

we haven't had an opportunity to speak

yet, but I wanted to say thank you for

your leadership. And I think um it is

unfortunate that we got to this place.

What is fortunate is that we have

leaders like you and other members of

the community that are keeping us honest

about a promise that we made to the

community. And while this is not what

the original intention is, my hope and

why I'm supportive of these pieces of

legislation moving forward is because we

are ensuring that everything that folks

talked about that kids, my kids, my kids

kids can have a place to play and that

no matter who you are, that you have a

place that you can call um yours that's

outside and while what no matter your

age, you can experience the joy of being

outside. And I think when we've made

that promise to a community, we have to

be honest about what that looks like.

And like I said, it's unfortunate the

way that we got here, but I do

appreciate the fact that we are coming

together to say, how do we make this

better? And how do we ensure that people

get the things that they need at the end

of the day? And so, continue to keep us

honest, okay?

>> And um I'm sure you will. You don't need

me to tell you that. Um but um but also,

thank you for the continued

conversations. And my hope is that what

we get at the end of this is even

better, right? Cuz sometimes we have

that opportunity to dream bigger to make

it even better. And if there's multiple

places now in a place that never had

something, then there has to be a good

that came of this. So thank you.

>> Okay. Thank you,

>> President Proim Dors.

>> Thank you, Council Member Chair. Just

again, thanks for coming down. Uh again,

I know uh the level of frustration that

you had last week uh was I think

righteous uh where we were at and um

knowing that this last week things have

changed and folks have continued to work

with you in good faith. Um I've believed

in my council colleagues that made a lot

of commitments when this came to vote

came before council for a vote. You know

ultimately I was not supportive of that

at that time simply because the things

that are happening now in my view should

have happened you know months ago. But

again to council member bro David Dia's

point like we can't keep relitigating

history at this point. It's about make

doing what we need to to make sure that

the folks um in that community get get

what they were promised. And I just want

to thank you for earnestly moving that

forward. And you know, frankly, I've

been, you know, watching the agenda to

see as additional pieces of of this deal

come forward uh with great skepticism

and knowing that you're in support of

the two things that are before us

tonight says everything I need to know

about where I'm going to be and that is

very helpful to see folks, you know,

meaningfully engaging to hopefully again

achieve both these things that uh folks

would like to see happen in our

community. So, uh, I it's great to see

you, um, you know, much much more

pleasant, uh, mood this week

considering, uh, the progress that has

been made and that's something that I

think everyone at that table should

have, uh, you know, a lot of optimism

about. So, thanks for for being here and

sharing that with us.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you. Uh, seeing no other questions

or comments from my colleagues. Thank

you again, Miss Reed, for uh, being

here.

>> Thank you.

>> Uh, so with that, I will first uh, move

to amend submitted to the clerk.

Second clerk,

>> please call the role.

>> Bankston, Bar Roa, de Padilla, Dors,

Remy, Ross, Swiss, President Hart.

>> Amended.

>> And now I move for um now I move to for

adoption as amended by voice.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Bankston Rosa Padilla Dors Reie by

voice.

>> Let me go back.

>> Can we go back? Let's reconsider the

amendment.

>> Just click call by voice.

>> Okay. Bankston. Yes.

>> Padilla.

>> Yes.

>> No. Abstain.

>> Just say yes. You can do

>> a yes.

>> Okay. She's a yes.

>> Mhm. Okay. Dorren,

>> yes.

>> Remy,

>> yes.

>> Ross,

>> yes.

>> President Hard,

>> yes. Pass.

>> Thank you. And that's all I have in my

committee this evening.

>> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Uh, the next

committee to come before council

is the public service interpretation

committee. That committee is chaired by

council member Rosa Deia. Council floor

is yours.

>> Thank you. Thank you to my colleagues

for trying to keep me honest. I got you.

I got you. I got you. Um, okay. So,

council president, I have two ordinances

today in public service and

transportation. So, the first I am very

excited about. Um, this is ordinance

10562026

to authorize the transfer of

appropriation within the streets

construction maintenance and repair fund

to authorize the director of public

service to modify a a contribution

agreement with the greater Columbus Arts

Council Incorporated in support of the

Mothers of Murdered Columbus Children

Art Memorial to accept on behalf of the

city title and ownership of the

completed artwork and add it to the

city's art collection upon final

acceptance and required approvals and to

declare an emergency So, we have a

number of speakers if y'all want to

start making your way up as a group. Um,

our representatives from MOCC and GCAC.

Um, so I want to first thank my

colleagues, Council Member Ross, Council

Member Reie, and Council Member Deakau,

who also contributed uh to making this

possible. So, um, just a reminder for

folks, a few a while back, uh, mothers

of murdered Columbus children, um, came

together, and I want to acknowledge a

number of them are here with us today.

Um, came together to do a memorial. They

were putting locks on one of our

bridges. Unfortunately, there was a

little bit of miscommunication. It was

the locks were taken down. And in

conversations together, we decided that

a fitting a more fitting tribute than

just even the locks were to really

memorialize

uh folks who have died um from violent

deaths due to gun violence. That this

could be a tribute to uh the mothers who

have lost their children, but also a

memorial for the entire city to come

around. a place of peace and healing, a

place that we could come together as a

city um to honor the folks that we have

lost way too soon. So um throughout this

process, we started it last year during

the last couple months, a jury has come

together. I was honored to be part of

that jury to select artists. We did a

national call to artists um to come

together to design a piece. Uh the D

concept has been chosen by the jury. An

announcement is soon to come. But I um

want to acknowledge all of the folks who

were part of making this um process.

There were folks from the

administration, folks from city council,

GCAC helped to lead the way. I want to

thank the department who first brought

this to us and said, "Hey, what can we

do here?" Um, thank you for uh kind of

on the theme that we were going, keeping

us honest and saying, "Hey, we have an

opportunity, not just to make this right

for um this for these mothers, but for

all mothers, for all people who have

lost someone." So, I want to thank all

the folks, this coalition that has come

together. I think it is well, we talk a

lot about the Columbus Way, and to me,

this is the best example of the Columbus

Way. This is how we bring people from

cross-sections of the community together

to create um uh really places of

healing, places of magic, and places

where the community really sees

themselves. So, I want to welcome Mch

Mch Mitch Menaka,

um the uh new well, I can't even say

that anymore, our CEO of GCAC and also

um our representative from Mothers of

Murdered Columbus Children. The floor is

yours.

Good evening, President Harden, Council

Member Barrosa Depodilla, and members of

the council. Thank you for the

opportunity to mark this important

milestone. I am proud to be joined by

Carla Harris, Melissa Stlair, and

members of the Mothers of Murdered

Columbus Children and our public art

team today. Today's funding is more than

a step forward in a project. It reflects

a sustained commitment from the city of

Columbus to honor the lives of the

children lost to violence and to stand

alongside the mothers of murdered

Columbus children. Over the past several

months, this process has been shaped by

deep engagement with MOMCC members,

community voices, and city partners,

ensuring that we create not only a

memorial, but something that is truly

reflects the values and experiences of

those it is meant to serve.

Public art invites dialogue and

engagement across diverse communities,

helping people feel seen, welcomed, and

connected to the places where they live,

work, and gather. It strengthens

communities by making art accessible to

everyone,

including the local folks and stories

and cultures, and inviting the community

to participate in creating vibrant

environments for residents and visitors.

Through that process, a final artist has

been selected. While we are not yet able

to say their name, we can say that their

proposal reflects a thoughtful and

powerful vision, one that creates a

place, not just an object. It will offer

spaces of gathering, quiet reflection,

ceremony, and everyday visitation. It

considers accessibility, comfort, and

care through elements like seating,

shade, and moments of pause while

honoring the stories and presidents ofc

families.

As we move into the next phase,

important work lies ahead. Design

refinement, technical coordination, and

continued collaboration will ensure that

this vision is realized with the care

and integrity it deserves. We are

grateful to our city partners for their

continued support, especially to the

members of the MOC for their trust,

leadership, and willingness to guide

this process. Thank you.

>> Want to say anything?

>> I'm good.

Thank you.

>> Um I also would be remiss if I did not

thank uh Director Reese and her team

when we were looking for land. This is

um part of our land with Wreck and

Parks. They will help to maintain it.

This is along the Sciota. So this will

be a beautiful piece that we can add to

our collection as a city. We're inching

closer and closer to more beautiful

spaces everywhere that do provide that

healing um for folks to go to. Do my

colleagues have any questions, comments?

>> I just want to say thank you, council

member, first for offering us the

opportunity to participate. Um, I have

always been a fan of Melissa Sinclair

and the mothers of mothers of Columbus,

mothers of murder Columbus children. Um,

turning imaginable, unimaginable grief

into advocacy and having because nothing

can replace the lives lost. Literally

nothing can replace the lives lost. But

having a permanent fixture that provides

refuge and healing um is is really just

the most appropriate response that we as

a city can have um to support you to

support all of your work and really uh

to continue this call for action for

safer communities. Um this is a place

that you can use to help elevate your

mission and your message and I am so

proud to have been a part of supporting

this. So thank you council member.

>> Absolutely. And I just want to say I

don't think I've had the opportunity. Um

this is in the most Columbus of stories.

Melissa and I actually went to high

school together and um that was Eastmore

High School if anyone didn't know. Um

and our our um our mascot is the

Warriors. We're warriorettes and that

warrior spirit lives in you. And I think

also in every single one of the moms who

are part of MOCC and who show up every

day and who advocate for um better

legislation, who advocate for their

sons, their daughters, and the people

that they lost to ensure that our city

is safer. And thank you for always

keeping us honest and for making us

better and making us a safer city for

everyone. So, um, yes, council member,

>> I just want to thank you as well and

thank you to the other council members

that helped fund this. Uh, you know, it

was an unfortunate situation that

happened and looked, it was a dark day

when that happened and of course, we

needed to make this right. And so, it's

exciting to think about what's going to

become because it's going to be

something much more than what it was.

and it'll be a place for this entire

community to see, you know, the the pain

that people have felt, but then the

passion that you bring every single day

in this community. And so, we just

really thank you for your leadership in

the community and all the things that

you do to help support safer

communities. And we love you. Thank you.

And my last shout out, I would be remiss

if I did not thank Director Skako, and

he's not always out front, but Deputy

Director Randy Bourne Treger, who first

brought this and said, "We have to do

something." And first put the dollars

down, and then we joined in to make this

um better for everyone. And so, I can't

wait for the day that we cut this

ribbon. I can't wait for the day this is

going to be such a beautiful place of

solace and peace and healing for

everyone. So, with that, um I move for

passage.

Bankston Barrosa Deodia adorns Remy Ross

Swice President Harden

>> passed.

>> Thank you. One step closer y'all.

And next, see, it's always good when we

have we have good things to y'all. Okay.

Next is um ordinance 1163 20226 to amend

the 2025 capital improvement budget to

authorize a city auditor to transfer

cash and appropriation within various

funds to authorize the establishment of

an auditor certificate for construction

inspection and administration fees and

to authorize the expenditure of up to

1,375,5672720

from various funds for the purpose of

providing sufficient funding for

construction inspection and

administration services on public

service projects. So construction

inspection funding is generally

estimated by taking a percentage of the

construction costs. Occasionally the

funds set up for this uh estimated costs

are not sufficient to cover the

inspection of the project through

completion due to project related

unforeseen conditions, weather,

construction change orders, etc. So this

ordinance essentially provides the

funding for that inspection and

administrative deficits for capital

improvements projects for the department

of public service. Do my colleagues have

any questions or comments?

>> Seeing none, I move for passage.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Thanks. Tim Barroso de Padilla Dors Remy

Ross Vice President Hart

>> passed.

>> Thank you. Um council president in her

absence may I move to page 18 in health

and human services and equity. Um so I

vice chair health and human services and

equity committee and we have one

ordinance this evening and that is

ordinance 1373 2026 to authorize and

direct the board of health to accept the

uh fiscical year 27 reproductive health

and wellness grant from the Ohio

Department of Health in the amount of

1,332,87

to authorize the appropriation of 1,332

um,87

and any additional funds from the

unappropriated balance of the health

department grants fund and to declare an

emergency. The FY27 reproductive health

and wellness program will allow family

planning and reproductive health

services including contraception, cancer

screening and sexual health with target

populations including vulnerable men,

women and teens, minorities, special

populations such as residents with

substance use disorder in incarcerated

individuals and those experienced

homelessness. We estimate that this

grant will serve 8,000 visits this year

alone. Do my colleagues have any

questions or comments? Seeing none, I

move for passage.

>> Second clerk, please call the role.

>> Banks Rosa de Padilla Dors Remy Ross

Weiss President Hard

>> passed.

>> Thank you. Almost done. Can we move to

rules and reference on page 22,

>> please?

>> Thank you. Um, so this next piece of

legislation has been in the works for

quite some time. Since 2024, transit

advocates have approached the city

advocating for a complete streets

policy. This policy is about safety.

It's about ensuring that we are

prioritizing cyclists, pedestrians, and

the most vulnerable users when we design

and construct our uh roadways. So, in

winter 2023, we had an alarming number

of serious pedestrian crashes and

fatalities, and residents and advocates

were demanding for safety measures. In

spring 2024, I with the Department of

Public Service organized roundts with

local transit advocates to discuss

topics face-to-face with residents and

they were able to express their

concerns. This resulted in a resounding

request for complete streets policy. In

July 2024, we held a hearing with Morpsy

updating us on their regional complete

streets policy that have been adopted by

many of our fellow uh uh municipalities

within the region. Then in 2025 October,

we held another hearing on complete

streets with DPS updating residents on

complete streets within the department,

which brings us to today. So, ordinance

13922026

to require the uh director of the

Department of Public Service to adopt

and regularly evaluate a complete

streets policy for the city of Columbus

to amend sections 213.034

to enact section 21005.02

and to repeal the existing version of

section 219.034

of the Columbus City Codes. The code

change defines complete streets policy

to mean a set of guidelines and internal

policies that emphasize the

consideration of safety for all public

infrastructure users including

pedestrians, cyclists, motorists and

transit riders of all ages and abilities

during the planning, design and

construction of public infrastructure.

This change uh this code change also

requires the director to issue a report

to city council and the mayor annually

to detail any changes made to the policy

and to review new recommendations and

best practices issued by the national

national association of city

transportation officials, the national

complete streets coalition, the American

Planning Association, other relevant

organizations since the previous report.

So we do have two speakers in favor of

this ordinance. So, first I'd like to

call up from Transit Columbus, Stevie

Pasamante, and then Dustin Holffinger

from the American Heart Association will

be next.

>> Stevie, welcome back to council.

>> Hello again. It feels like I'm here too

often. Uh, my name is Stevie Pasante and

I'm a board member for Transit Columbus

and I'm here to speak in support of the

adoption of the complete streets policy

into city code. It has been a long

couple of years to get to this point,

but I want to thank you for all of the

work that you've put in to adopt this

complete streets policy in the fall and

today to have it enshrined in city code.

I know it's a lot of effort, but it is a

worthwhile effort. Street design is a

public safety issue. When we talk about

public safety, I think we often focus on

crime and murder rates. But while there

were 85 homicides in the city of

Columbus last year, 103 people were

killed in fatal crashes in Franklin

County in 2025, at least 70 of which

were in the city of Columbus and another

354 were seriously injured beyond that.

As our friends at the American Heart

Association will tell you, I'm sure

street design is also a public health

issue. Most people don't have the time

or money to carve out to go to the gym

regularly, but having a safe way to

walk, bike, or roll, keeps people

active, prevents a wide range of health

issues, and ultimately lowers health

care costs. Increasingly, street design

is an affordability issue.

Transportation is the second highest

household cost next to housing itself.

And with the rising cost of gas and cars

and housing and everything else,

Columbus residents should not be forced

into shouldering the cost of personal

vehicles. simply because they have no

other choice. So, thank you for putting

in the work to give our residents more

choice. There's a lot that happens in

between these public hearings and it's

for that reason that I'm really

appreciative that council member and DPS

have elected to review this policy on an

annual basis to ensure that we are

constantly learning, iterating, and

experimenting with ways to build a more

walkable, more bikable, more transit

friendly, and yes, even more drivable

city. When we first commented on this

policy a couple years ago, we urged the

city to adopt the best complete streets

policy in the country. We are much

closer to that than we were then. Uh but

we are still getting beat by cities in

Texas and New Jersey. So, I'm confident

that we can work together to get get to

that place even if we aren't there now.

To that end, I ask that we keep the ball

rolling and work to reinstate the

transportation and pedestrian commission

established in chapter 21103 of city

code. Uh, and otherwise, thank you to

every advocate who helped push for this

and thank you council member and to

director Scotto and DPS for continuing

to move us forward a little bit more

safely.

>> Thank you. Thank you, Stevie, for being

here today.

Dustin, come on down.

Hi, good afternoon. My apologies for

reading from my phone. My printer was

broken today. I've never done this

before, so hopefully it doesn't time

out. Uh, I want to start by thanking you

all for your time, your leadership, and

your genuine interest in the city of

Columbus complete streets policy. At the

American Heart Association, we know that

the design of our communities directly

impacts the health of our residents and

safe walkable neighborhoods are

essential act for active living. So

Stevie was right. Right now, the

Department of Public Safety or

Department of Public Service has an

excellent forward-thinking framework on

paper. However, by taking this next step

to integrate this policy directly into

your city code, you all have the great

opportunity to turn great internal staff

guidance into permanent municipal law.

This cotification is exactly what we

need to be build real long-term

accountability that ensure safe

equitable streets are a legal

requirement for every project in our

city from day one planning to routine

maintenance. As you review this

framework and work to lock in these

design standards into your code, I

strongly encourage you to keep the door

open, open to community engagement and

deeply engaging with that community. One

concrete way to do this would be to

reinstate the transportation and

pedestrian commission. With this

advisory board in place, the depart the

public service director and council

would receive direct input from a body

that will hold open meetings, giving

residents consistent opportunities to

provide valuable feedback on local

transportation conditions. The people

who live, work, and commute in your

neighborhoods every day possess the best

firsthand insight

into how our streets can be safer and

more comfortable for everyone, whether

they are walking, biking, driving, or

catching the bus. By maintaining an

active trans or transparent dialogue and

making sure your outreach meets those

residents where they are, council can

ensure this ordinance will truly reflect

the needs of our diverse community while

helping to repair the past inequities

and potential for in our urban planning.

Thank you again for your commitment.

We'll say that again. Thank you again

for your commitment. It's been a long

time coming to a safer, more connected

Columbus. I urge you to move forward

with codifying this policy and keep

working hand inand with the community as

you work to build the future.

>> Thank you, Dustin. Thank you for being

here and thank you for your continued

advocacy. Director, I do want to You're

good. I think we're good.

>> Yeah. Um director, I do want to two

things. Um one is just so my colleagues

also understand part of the complete

streets policy. The the department

always had one as part of kind of their

policies. putting into code gives us a

little bit more teeth for us to continue

to revisit it. It's this is really about

um we know that if we improve our

infrastructure, it can help to uh ensure

that there will be human error, right?

We we will be distracted. We can be the

best drivers, we can tell people to lock

in, we can tell them to put down their

phones, but if your baby's crying in the

back, if something drops in the car,

even a minute of distraction, we know

can be detrimental. And so by

redesigning our streets to allow for

that human error, but to ensure that

it's safer um is really what Complete

Streets is about, right? It's about how

we do that and the principles that we

use to make our streets safer. And so by

putting it into code, it really gives us

that accountability for us to revisit it

year-over-year, for us to ensure that

there's best practices there and for us

to continue to keep us honest on the

promises that we're making to the

community. So, director, I want to give

you the floor as well if there's

something that you want to add to the

legislation.

>> Good evening again, President Harden,

Chair Barisa Depia, other members of

council. Uh, complete streets are

designed to serve everyone in this

community regardless of how they travel.

They balance the needs of all users

within a safe, comfortable, and

integrated environment suitable for the

surrounding development. As you said,

council member, we have been using these

practices since 2008 and incorporating

complete streets, you know, into all of

our design practices. And we are

constantly looking around the country

and at our own designs to see how we can

make our streets even safer. Complete

streets is a key component for our

vision zero initiative, aiming to

eliminate roadway fatalities by 2035.

Early data from April indicates we've

achieved our second month without any

traffic fatalities on Columbus roads

this past year, which is a huge win.

>> That's huge.

>> Every fatality we mourn, but a month

that we do not have these fatalities is

so critical. Our numbers are a little

different than Miss Pasamonte's, but you

know, we had a high of 74 deaths in

2021. Last year, we were down to 48. So,

we really truly feel like our efforts

are paying off. We are on the right

track and we're happy to codify the

department's existing complete streets

policy tonight as we move forward on our

goal to support vision zero efforts to

end traffic deaths and foster resilient

interconnected neighborhoods for

everyone. And if folks from home want to

find out more about this subject, we

encourage them to go to our website at

uh columbus.gov/visionzero.

I had the opportunity to sit on a um

there was a uh two book authors. They

also have a podcast and they talked

about life after cars. And one of the

things that we know to be true is that

it has become essentially a standard

since really um since the car industry

was really born that um there has been

uh fatalities due to car crashes in the

five to six figure number year over

year. And it has become something that

we're all accustomed to that that is in

order if we're going to have a car, this

thing is true. And this is why vision

zero is so important. This is why

complete streets and these policies are

so important too. I think you know

Stevie you made an excellent point of

we're making people have tough decisions

of a house or a car and how do you have

both and so ensuring in things like link

us and the other mobility opportunities

that we have could help to change the

game for people. Director there is one

last question that I have just around a

commission. Can you talk a little bit

about why we currently do not have that

commission because I know it is part of

code. Can you talk a little bit about

that and what might the future plans be?

>> Yes, we are currently using our vision

zero Columbus committee as a commission

that reviews the our policies on you

know our best practices. Um we also have

the bike plus engagement that we've done

extensive engagement with. Vision Zero

Columbus has an extens extensive

engagement and as part of you know link

us we're always out there engaging with

the public. We are sharing all of our

databased

experience that we have. I we make our

decisions based on data lots of data. Um

and it allows us to really move that

needle. I will say that I will give a

shout out to my transportation team both

the planners and the engineers. We have

absolutely the best transportation team

in Ohio. If not, I'd put them against

anyone in the country as far as being

able to safely go out there and design

and be so compassionate and willing to

look at our our designs and make sure

that we're designing the best safest

streets for the residents of Columbus.

>> Sure. And I would love for us to have

continued conversations about, you know,

I think all of those um all those

engagements have a specific purpose, but

what that might look like in the future

just because I think that, you know, as

we have the GBTQ commission and the um

the immigrant refugee commission, I

think having that voice has been so key.

So, if there's ways that we can work

together to look at what that looks like

in the future for that continued kind of

engagement, um we we will continue to

have those conversations. So, do my

colleagues have additional questions or

comments?

>> I think my only question was the

opportunity for public input to that

commission, but it sounds like your

>> Yeah, I think that's something that we

want to continue. Okay. Thank you.

>> That we want to continue to have

conversations about about what it looks

like since, you know, I think the

intentionality is a little bit

different, but what that looks like. Um,

seeing no additional questions or

comments, I move for passage.

>> Thanks. Timber Rosa Deia Dors Remy Ross,

Vice President Harden.

>> Great. And that is I'm so excited. I

also just want to say I'm very excited

to preview coming up very soon and

thankful to the department that um as we

think about complete streets and other

things we are looking at setting aside a

fund that would actually go towards

mobility towards innovation towards

other things. So more good things to

come but I want to thank you for our

residents and advocates who have been

working and hanging in there with us. I

want to also thank the department for

your partnership um and uh continued um

commitment to ensuring that everyone

gets to where they want to go and gets

home safely as well. So, thank you,

Council President.

>> Thank you, Madam Chair.

Uh

I think we'll we'll go ahead and let's

see if you can do it.

>> He's fast.

>> The next committee to come before

council is a neighborhood recreation and

parks committee chaired by council

member Deakar. In her absence, the vice

chair is council member White. He will

read that committee. Council member Flor

is yours.

>> Thank you, Council President. Uh,

tonight in Neighborhoods, Recreation,

and Parks Committee, we have four

ordinances up for second reading. First

is going to be 0921-2026

to authorize and direct the city clerk

to enter a grant agreement with Native

American Indian Center of Central Ohio

to provide upfront support for their

outdoor programming and to authorize an

expenditure from the neighborhood

initiative sub fund. I'm gonna kick it

to council member Rosa de Padilla to

talk a little bit more about this

ordinance.

>> Thank you. Thanks everyone for coming

this evening. I'll be here all week.

Okay. Um I just want to is are Ty Oh,

good. Come on down. Ty and Masami. Um we

have for a number of years since I came

into council uh we have been supporting

the work of Nikico. Nikico is an

organization uh that is dedicated to

preserving and restoring balance driven

values and initiative focused on

cultural preservation, restoration,

social development and economic

development and sustainability. Uh the

funding for this year will assist with

program related costs through 2026

related to Nikico Outdoors. So my

friends, it is so good to see you. It's

been a long time. I first was um engaged

with the Native American Center when I

was a city core member and actually did

service there and many times we came

back to partner and do service. I think

especially at this time when we um when

we are trying to erase history when we

are uh so many of our identities are

under attack continuing to preserve um

our native culture is so key in cultures

around the world and certainly here. And

so that's why the work that you all do

is so key um to ensuring that we

preserve culture, that we um understand

our history. And so that is why I always

have a commitment to this organization

year over year. So I would love to give

you the floor to talk more about your

mission and the work and what this

funding is going towards.

>> VA, greetings everyone. President

Harden, council members, thank you for

having us here and allowing us to

>> You have to go closer

>> like a little bit closer.

>> Listen to your wife, they say. Um,

always good to come back here. Um, the

experiences have definitely been good.

Um, we just really are appreciative on

behalf of those that, you know, we

represent, uh, who personify our mission

and vision work. We definitely want to

say ka, thank you for the love and

support that you've extended our way

over the years. Um, yeah, we're just

we're super excited to uh to receive

this funding. It really advances the

good work that we've already been able

to do through the funding that we've

received from you guys already. So, you

know, it's just uh

maybe just to kind of share a little bit

too so people can be a little bit, you

know, more privy to what we're what

we're doing in terms of what we're the

the programming is called Niko Outdoors

and uh it's really about allowing our

people access to the outdoors and you

know, in a lot of ways, our culture is

tied to mother nature. Uh what we find

is that a lot of our people are really

just kind of uh consumed with their

lives, you know, kind of in the urban

setting. And so we're seeing people that

want to decompress and, you know, get

outside. And so we're accessing, you

know, a lot of different things through

fishing, through foraging, gathering, uh

just being able to, you know, just feel

the air, you know, be in the water, you

know, listen to the birds, and a lot of

these things really tie into our our

cultural pathways. And so it's just it's

really awesome that uh we've been able

to come this far. And again, you know,

to to have the love and support that you

guys have extended our way. And uh I

want to say to you Lordes, I just want

to say thank you for the few years back

when you first reached out to us. You

know, very meaningful at that point in

time and it really was a shot in the arm

that we needed too. So and to uh to

everybody else too for your support.

Thank you my wife.

>> Good afternoon or good evening. Um

uh and Mimi

Masami Smith, executive director for the

Native American Indian Center of Central

Ohio.

Um

I just I want to say thank you uh that

means I'm grateful.

Um, Columbus City Council has really

lifted up our our our native community

here in Ohio and we touched the four

corners of the state. People, we're

like, you know, the main Indian center

in Ohio that everybody comes to for

help, for resources. Um, and our current

initiative

is, you know, the gathering and

foraging. And this is the most important

thing to our our people our people all

over Indian country.

>> And this this um helps them to ground

themselves and belong to the creator to

um all of our cultural ceremonies.

Um and this is what helped us survive

all these these years of trying to

survive and restore our culture. So I

just want to say thank you. I really

appreciate you

and um yeah, we're grateful. Thank you

so much.

>> I just want to say to my colleagues,

this is on the south side. Woo! Woo! Um

if you've not been, please head to the

center. I had the opportunity to go to

one of the harvesting feasts and it was

the most beautiful experience. And

there's also a food truck so if you're

having an event or you want to follow

along and have some great um uh what are

they called? fluffy the tacos. No, the

>> tacos.

>> Um they're amazing. So, please see where

the food truck is going to be somewhere

uh this summer because this is also

another way that you can support the

cause. Do my colleagues have any

additional comments or questions.

Great. Seeing none, I move for passage.

>> Second.

>> I'm sorry. Um just kidding. I am

amending as submitted. That's what I'm

doing. Is there a second? Second. Clerk,

please call the row.

>> Banks Timber Rosa de Padilla, Dorren,

Remy Ross, Swice, President Harden.

>> Amended.

>> And now I move for passage.

>> Second.

>> Please call the row.

>> Banks Timber Rosa Day Padilla Dors Remy

Ross Wash President Harden. Pass.

>> Congratulations. Thank you so much.

>> Thank you, Vice Chair. You're giving me

real honest today. I appreciate it.

>> The floor is back to you.

>> Trying to move it along here. All right.

So next I have ordinance 1086-2026

to authorize the director of Reen Parks

Department to modify an existing

contract with Clare Weiss Architects LLP

doing business as WXY architect

architecture and urban design for the

Lynen Green Line project to authorize

the appropriation of $743,948.51

within the recreation and parks

permanent improvement fund to authorize

the transfer of $1,13,92724

within in the recreation and parks voted

bond fund and permanent improvement fund

to authorize the transfer of

$2,426,452.90

between the general fund income tax set

aside sub fund and the recreation and

parks bond fund to authorize the

appropriation of $2,426,452.90

in the income tax set that may be on

here. No, that's good. income tax set

aside fund and recreation and parks

voted bond fund to authorize the

amendment of the 2025 capital

improvement budget uh to authorize the

expenditure of 3,600,000

from the recreation and parks voted bond

fund and permanent improvement fund and

to declare an emergency. This ordinance

provides the funding for continued

design and engineering services for

phases one and two of the Lynen Green

Line project. This project will provide

seven linear miles and 58 acres of trail

and park space to the Lynen Northland

communities. Emergency designation is

requested to ensure that phases one and

two construction plans are ready for

bidding and comply with grant

requirements. Let me stop there. See if

any questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Second.

>> Click, please call the row.

>> Bankston Barrosa Deodia Dorance Remy

Ross President Harden

>> pass. Thank you. Thank you. Next, I have

ordinance 1087-2026

to authorize the transfer of $24,500

from the Sustainable Columbus Fund to

the Recreation and Park Special Purpose

Fund to support the Tree Assistance

Program in partnership with Franklin

Soil and Water Conservation District.

The Tree Assistance Program or TAP

allows private land owners to apply for

funds to plant trees on their private

property. This program is crucial to

meeting the goals of our urban forestry

master plan as most of the land

available to expand our community's tree

canopy is on private property. Let me

stop there. See if any questions or

comments from my colleagues. Seeing

none, I move for passage.

>> Second.

>> Please call the role.

>> Bankston Barrosia adorns Remy Ross vice

president Harden

>> pass. And last in recreation uh

neighborhood recreation parks committee

I have ordinance 1407-2026

to authorize the director of recreation

and parks department to modify an

existing contract with Kim Leehorn and

Associates Incorporated to extend the

contract term through December 31st,

2027 to allow for continued

architectural and engineering services

for the Gender Road Park and McCory Park

Improvements Project and to declare an

emergency. This ordinance is a positive

step forward to follow through on the

promise to deliver recreational space

for the southwest community. With this

contract modification, the vendor can

now start redesigning therapeutic

recreation originally planned for McCory

Park at alternate sites. Emergency

designation is requested in order to

meet the end of June 2026 deadline that

has been set for the working group to

identify alternative spaces. While we

were all disappointed in the process,

I'm excited that we're are starting to

earn back the trust and confidence from

the community members. Uh we did have

one speaker signed up, uh Commissioner

Reid, but I believe she is gone. Uh

>> yeah, she did it earlier. So I think

we've heard her comments there. Let me

stop and see if there are any questions

or comments from my colleagues.

>> Seeing none, I move for passage.

>> Second.

>> Clerk, please call the row. Bankston

Barrosa de Padilla Dors Remy Ross Vice

President Harden

>> passed. Thank you. That is all I have in

uh neighborhoods recreation and parks

committee. May I move on to public

utilities and sustainability or are we

pausing for zoning?

>> I'm actually going to Can can you do

weld in a few? I'm going to go back in

order. We'll come back to you.

Weld

>> trying to get some out the way. The next

committee to come before council is the

workforce education labor committee

chair by press the floor is yours. Uh,

thank you, Council President. Tonight in

the well committee, we have ordinance

1162-2026

to amend the police management

compensation plan, ordinance number

2715-203

as amended by enacting section 7J by uh

amending section 8G and uh enacting

section 14C and declared emergency. Uh

last week, the mayor announced a renewal

of police chief Elaine Bryant's contract

for additional 5 years with the city of

Columbus. I know I'm not the only member

of this body that thanks her for her

service uh to the city. Uh she's done a

fantastic job and very excited to know

that um she'll be continuing her service

with the city of Columbus. Uh as a

result of the negotiations between the

the chief and the city of Columbus,

updates the police management

compensation plan are necessary to

reflect the new terms um of employment

for Chief Bryant. Uh HR director Alicia

Martin is here um to walk us through

those changes. Dr. Martin, floor is

yours.

>> Good evening, Council President Harden,

Council President Proim Dorren. Oh,

>> pull the mic up to you.

>> Good evening.

>> There you go.

>> Sorry.

>> Good evening, Council President Harden,

Council President Prom Dorans, and other

members of council. Um, so these changes

coincide with Chief Bryant's uh recent

acceptance of a second 5-year term,

which begins on June 25th, 2026. There

are three um primary changes to the

police MCP. The first one includes the

addition of a mutual separation clause

that allows for an em amicable

separation should the police chief and

city of Columbus find it in the best

interest of both parties to sever the

employment relationship before the

5-year terms is up. This lumpsum payment

is subject to approval by both the

director of human resources and the

director of public safety and will

expire um upon chief prime chief Brian's

final term on June 30th, 2031.

The second change is to increase the

term life insurance. The police chief

classification right now for the city

maintains a life insurance policy for

one and a half times the salary. this um

currently does not exceed $200,000. And

so um we are changing the language to

not only increase to the full amount of

the salary, but also avoid a reduction

um should the police chiefs in the

future um exceed ages 65 or 70 years of

age. This change recognizes the unique

demands and high risks associated with

public safety and serving as police

chief for a large and rapidly expanding

metropolitan area such as Columbus,

Ohio. And the third change is um to

allow the police chief to be eligible

for sick leave reciprocity. Um, the

addition of this language will allow the

police chief an opportunity each year to

elect either to be paid out unused sick

leave at their regular hourly rate,

carry over the sick leave to the next

year or split the remaining balance

50/50 between a carryover um and a

payout. This reflects both the city's

support for retention and employee

well-being, but will also serve as a

strong recruitment tool making the

opportunity more compet more more

competitive when we fill the position in

the future. Thank you.

>> Thank you, Director Martin. Uh

questions, my colleagues for director

Martin. Seeing none, uh again, just want

to point out that the sunsetting

provision for these changes will expire

on June 30th of 2031 unless there's

additional action taken by this body. Um

any comments from anyone else? Seeing

none, I move for passage.

>> Clerk, please call the role.

>> Banks timber adorns Remy Ross, Vice

President Harden.

>> Passed.

>> Thank you, Council President. Can I do

rules and reference?

>> I would if I were you.

>> Thank you, sir. Um in rules of

reference, I have ordinance number

1265-2026 to amend chapter 378 of the

community benefits uh agreement advisory

committee. Uh this code change will

protect the city and city contractors

against accidental non-compliance with

the city's uh community benefits

agreement advisory committee procedures

by requiring that all contracting

agencies of the city to include notice

in all solicitations informing them of

the committee the committee's procedures

and the possibility of a recommendation

of a community benefit agreement. Uh

this will ensure the council's goal

around workforce development, use of

unionized construction, labor, and the

community benefits uh are further

realized through our own city

construction projects. Um through our

work through the CBA advisory committee

um through the implementation of these

agreements um and allowing us to have

better contracting procedures to ensure

that when these requirements are put in

place that all contractors are put on

notice as early as possible in the

contracting process uh to ensure that

all folks are playing from an uh level

playing field. Any questions or comments

from my colleagues? Seeing none, I move

for passage.

>> Second. Cler, please call the role.

>> Thanks. Temporarosa deodori Ross, vice

president Harden.

>> Pass.

>> Thank you. Next, we have ordinance

number 1477-2026

amend chapter 378, the committee

benefits agreement to amend section

111.04 of the Columbus City codes

pertaining to council committees and to

create a new ad hoc committee. Uh, this

code change will establish a new joint

committee between Columbus City Council

and the Columbus City School Board of

Education, creating a new body focused

on a shared responsibility for the

success for our school district for

students, families, teacher, support

staff, and our entire city. Uh we

announced this committee late last month

in a classroom at Northland High School

and we'll have our first meeting on

Monday, June 15th here in council

chambers and we're hitting the ground

running with an investment in the

Northland High School community campus

school pilot. Uh this committee will

explore new and innovative ways to

collaborate between city and the

district with no topic off the table

between our members here at council and

those uh at the school board. Uh I'm

personally very excited uh myself to use

our the city's land use tools to help

strategically manage public property

both owned by the city and the school

district. Uh I'm deeply appreciative of

of the board president Antoette Miranda

uh vice president Sarah Engles and

council president for our leadership

getting this committee off the ground.

And as the parent of a soon to be

kindergartener and I know the the dad's

caucus here has lots of kids that are

about to be in that position. Uh there's

no better time than now to make sure

that this body is doubling down uh on

its investment and its partnership with

Columbus City Schools uh to make sure

that all of our kids have an opportunity

to world-class education and to ensure

that they have the opportunities and the

tools to be successful right here in

Columbus. I did want to pause and and

turn the mic over to my partner in crime

on this with Council President Harden

who also has a kiddo who's about to head

off to kindergarten as well.

>> Yes, sir. Well, thank thank you uh Mr.

chair and it truly is a a a good step

forward as we um you know a lot of folks

know that uh the city schools and city

of Columbus are two different

institutions but the truth is the issues

that impact both of them cross uh cross

over and so this is an opportunity to

put everything on the table in front of

the two bodies uh to show a collective

and a realignment of how we do things

together uh to improve um the lives and

the ability to educate our young people

but also to move our city forward. And

so we look forward to uh open and frank

conversations and actually continue to

move uh policy uh forward in that

committee. And so uh thank you so much

for your your leadership and I look

forward to the work ahead.

>> Thank you, Council President. Appreciate

getting a chance to work with you and

the board president, vice president,

CCS. Lots to come on this. Very very

excited for um this body to lean in that

effort because we know that the success

of our kids is the success of this city.

Um, unless there's any other question or

comments from my colleagues, I move for

passage.

>> Second.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Thanks. Timber Ross Remy Ross Vice

President Harden

>> passed.

>> Thank council presidents. Uh, I will

make a motion for recess.

>> There we go. Is there a second?

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Banks Rossa de Padilla Dors Remy Ross,

Vice President Harden.

>> We are in recess.

Oh,

oh, oh.

Heat up

here.

Oh, oh, oh.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Yeah,

we

Hey,

hey, hey.

How about

feel?

N

a want a n

Hey,

N.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat. N.

Hey, hey, hey.

heat.

Hey

Heat.

Heat.

Hey,

hey, hey.

Heat. Heat.

I want to high

I want to you

happy.

Happy.

on the ground.

It's on the way.

I want to let you

I want to you

I

want to you

I feel you.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Hey. Hey. Hey.

Oh.

Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.

Heat. Heat.

That's

why

Heat. Heat.

Find

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Happy

birthday.

Natalie.

now come to order. Clerk, please call

the row.

>> Banks Denver Rosa De Padilla Dorne Remy

Ross Vice President Harden.

>> Can I get a motion to the reading of the

journal?

>> Second. Clerk, please call the role.

>> Banks Denver Rosa Day Padilla Dors Remy

Ross Vice President Harden. Are there

any additions or corrections to the

journal? Hearing the journal's approved,

we'll now go to the zoning committee.

Press pro Tim chair that committee. All

members serve on it. Uh floor is yours.

>> Thank you, Council President. Uh before

we get into tonight's uh zoning agenda,

u this is the second time in a couple

weeks we've had to postpone some piece

of legislation that has significant

amount of public interest. So, I want to

thank my colleagues, staff, and

certainly the public for their

understanding with the and their

flexibility. Uh we did have uh many

members of the public that are planning

to be here with us tonight to express

their opinions on the 2100 Hard Road

zoning ordinance. Uh however, that uh

ordinance has been postponed at the

applicant's request until June 8th. Uh,

as we've had the other postponements,

um, the city attorney's office has

confirmed that those who speed up those

who signed up to speak tonight will have

their speaker slips transferred to the

night uh, on June 8th that we will

consider that ordinance and there's no

reason to sign up um, to to speak again.

Uh, as always, I will go in and review

our rules

pertaining to speaking for council on

reszonings and variances. We only hear a

staff presentation. The ordinance have a

disapproval from recommending body or if

we have a public speaker assigned to

speak against an ordinance. We permit

three speakers on each side of an

ordinance, three proponents, three

opponents. We ask those speakers limit

the remarks to three minutes per the

standard rules of city council. All

speakers in the council variance

including city staff, air commissioners,

applicants, and members of the public

will be sworn in before they give

testimony. Again, that is only for

variances. Representative and air

commission are always able to speak on

ordinance. You do not need to fill out a

speaker slip. We do ask you alert city

staff of your intention to speak at this

hearing. Representative civic

association do need a fellow speaker

slip because civic associations are not

formally recognized under Columbus city

code. Uh this evening we have 17 public

speakers signed to speak on on

ordinances tonight in this this agenda.

Though again due to the postponing

pending legislation, many of those

speakers were notified of the new date

of those ordinance will be considered.

We do have six public speakers sign of

speak uh on legislation we'll be hearing

tonight. Uh on the advice of the city at

Turner's office, I will will now swear

in city staff. Please stand and raise

your right hand be sworn in. Um do you

swear affirm the testimony you're about

to give shall but the truth nothing but

the truth as you shall answer under

pains of penalty pery. If so, please say

I do.

>> I do.

>> Thank you.

Please let the record reflect that Tim

Dietrich for the Department of Building

Zone Services uh along with Toby

Celibreezy from the department,

Christopher Lur from the division of

planning, Dan Blushman for the division

of traffic management, uh deputy

director for housing strategies Aaron

Proer from the department of development

and manager of storm uh plan review and

storm water uh storm water management

section of Columbus water and power Greg

Fetner and deputy director John Lee. Did

I miss anyone? I don't think I got

everyone. All right, the let the river

reflect that all those people have been

sworn in. Now, um, first we have

ordinance number 09 or I'm sorry,

0290-2026

to reszone 2100 Hard Road being 5 0 plus

acre located the north side of hard road

100 plus feet west of Stonefront Drive

from LRR limited rural residential

district to AR1 apartment residential

district. Again, at the applicant's

request, I move to postpone this

ordinance to June 8th uh zoning

committee agenda. Any questions or

comments from my colleagues?

Um, please let the record reflect that

Scott Frederickson, Deborah Link, Lisa

Ca Casser, Nathan Brisone, Jill Brisco,

uh, Jonathan Bashars, and backup

speakers Aaron Newman, Julie Bashier

will have their speaker slips honored

for the June 8th meeting. I now move to

postpone.

>> Second.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Bankston Barrosa, Deodia, Dors, Remy

Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Postponed.

>> Thank you. Uh next we have ordinance

number 1035-2026

to reszone 7801 and 7809 Olangi River

Road being 5.82 plus acres located on

the west side of Tangi River Road 370

plus feet south of Club View Boulevard

from R1 Rural District to LR12 Limited

Apartment Residential District. Site

consists of two parcels, one developed

with a releer office and the other with

a single unit dwelling. The requested

reszoning will allow a townhouse

development with a proposed density of

4.4 four units per acre. Pro is approved

from city staff and the development

commission, but a disapproval from the

far northwest uh coalition uh civic

association. There is no area commission

that covers this area. Due to the

disapproval from the civic association,

we'll now hear a staff report from the

city staff. Starting with Mr. Tim

Dietrich from the Department of Building

Zoning Services. Floor is yours, sir.

Chair Dorren, President Harden, members

of council. The subject site consists of

two parcels developed with an office use

in a single unit dwelling both in the R1

residential district. The requested L12

limited apartment residential district

will allow a 26-unit town home

development as shown on the submitted

site plan and building elevations. North

and west of the site are single-unit

dwellings in the R8 restricted urban

residential district within Sharon

Township. South of the site are

single-unit dwellings in the PD4 planned

unit development district. East of the

site are offices, a fuel station, and a

multi-unit residential development in

the PSC planned shopping center and EU

exceptional use districts both within

Sharon Township.

The limitation text establishes

appropriate use restrictions

and supplemental development standards

addressing maximum unit count, density,

building setback, perimeter yard, site

access, parking, sidewalk placement,

open space, building design, and

includes commitments to develop the site

in accordance with the submitted site

plan and building elevations. The

requested L12 limited apartment

residential district will allow a towno

a town home development with a maximum

of 26 units consistent with the Columbus

growth strategies recommendation.

Although the proposed use is

inconsistent with the Northwest Plans

land use recommendation, it is

compatible with the density and

development standards of adjacent

residential developments. Additionally,

staff note that the provided building

elevations and site plan, which

demonstrates the applicant's commitment

to preserve mature trees along the

site's perimeter are both consistent

with the Northwest Plan design

guidelines. Lastly, the request is

consistent with the city's objective of

providing more housing in all areas of

the city and therefore city department's

recommendation is for approval. Thanks,

M. Mr. Dietrich. Uh, questions for my

colleagues.

>> Mr. Dietrich, I know that there's an

amendment that was submitted here uh

with this legislation that I think was

primarily in response to a number of

environmental concerns that uh neighbors

had posed during the lengthy um process

that there was engagement between the

applicant and and adjoining neighbors.

Can you talk a little bit about what

that that amendment you sort of subject

of that and sort of what it does?

>> Yes. Uh the amendment was a

um a revision to the limitation text

that is within this ordinance. Um and it

does provide um wording regarding the

mature tree and um other brush along the

uh applicants perimeter of the uh

property. Uh so they do have commitments

to to the best of their ability with

what is healthy and what is not um

invasive to preserve those natural

elements. So in essence, it's the

commitment of obviously in Ohio and lots

of other places, we have uh invasive

species from a tree standpoint. So this

is basically stating that you if it's

not not invasive and it's healthy, it

should remain throughout the

construction process.

>> That's correct.

>> Thank you. Um want to next turn the

floor over to Mr. Chris Lore from the

Division of Planning.

>> Thank you, Chair Dorren, President

Harden, and members of council. Planning

supports the proposal. The Northwest

plan recommends a portion of the site

for lowdensity residential with the

balance recommended in the Columbus

growth strategy for mixeduse one. The

plan notes that proposals to redevelop

existing residential uses may be

supported if the use and design are

compatible with surrounding areas. As

such, staff recognize that the proposed

use is compatible with surrounding uses

and is consistent with the Columbus

Growth Strategy recommendation.

Additionally, the Columbus Growth

Strategies residential design guidelines

include recommendations regarding the

buffering and screening of adjacent uses

and notes that mature trees provide

significant environmental benefits and

should be preserved where possible.

Since the original submitt, the

applicant has made revisions that

included commitments to the preservation

or replacement of those existing

perimeter trees as as just noted and has

provided building elevations as well.

Uh, additionally, a contemplated access

drive to club to Club View Boulevard was

also removed. Staff has reviewed the

building elevations and found them to be

consistent with the Columbus Growth

Strategies design guidelines and as such

staff is in support.

>> Thank you, Mr. Lord. So, one question

about the growth strategy

recommendation, which obviously is only

a recommendation at this point. It's not

the not the zoning district that's been

applied, but oftent times folks measure

density rightfully or wrongfully based

upon like how tall something is. So can

we compare contrast what's in this

application here today compared to what

is proposed uh within that u grow

strategy recommendation.

>> So for the portion of the site that's

recommended mixed juice one which would

support heights up to uh four stories

approximately um this is well within

that um within that recommendation.

Obviously there's slope u but the

measurement of height is really based on

kind of the average uh is my

understanding.

>> Thank you. Any uh question my colleagues

or Mr. floor. Seeing none, I will turn

it over to Mr. Bushmitt from the

Division of Traffic Management.

>> Thank you, Chair Dors, President Harden,

members of council. In regards to our

review of this application, please be

advised that the proposed access point

to this site is to be taken from State

Route 315, which is within the

jurisdiction of the Ohio Department of

Transportation.

The Ohio Department of Transportation

required a traffic impact study to

evaluate this proposed area of

development.

Based on the review of this traffic

impact study, the Ohio Department the

Ohio Department of Transportation is

requiring that only right in, left in,

and right out turning movements be

permitted at the proposed site access

point to State Route 315.

No vehicles will be permitted to make a

left turning movement to exit the

proposed site access point to State

Route 315.

Additionally, a shared use path is being

required along the frontage of this

site. With these comments and note, the

Department of Public Service has no

further concerns regarding this

application. I would be happy to answer

any questions.

>> Thank you, Mr. Bushman. Questions from

my colleagues?

Mr. Bushman, I did want to ask, so you

mentioned that the traffic study was at

the behest of of ODOT, considering we're

right up there on 315 under sort of

standard rule. So, let's say that this

development was happening somewhere else

and not right up on a state highway. Um,

normally we're talking about much larger

developments. We're talking about these

zoning changes. one in the grand scheme

of what this committee normally hears is

is relatively modest from a unit count.

Um what type of traffic study or

improvements um coming from that would

we normally see for for a project of

this size?

>> So absent any other extraneous factors,

this would typically be a traffic access

study and and it was considered a

traffic impact study because it did

consider the uh adjacent intersection to

the north, the signalized intersection

to look at those impacts and potential

interactions with that. So um that was

you know the department of

transportation can put restrictions or

requirements on their their permits. So

that that is what they did with this

particular application and applicant.

>> And to be clear for many folks uh

sometimes there's questions about hey

when do these improvements happen uh as

as applied to when the construction

occurs. So you can like walk folks

through sort of how you know when those

traffic improvements that are being

required here would happen as it relates

to the development itself the proposed

development itself.

>> So that that would occur with the

development of the site. I mean there

would be no um you know ODOT will not

grant a a permit for their their site

access until they uh complete the

improve or make the appropriate uh

representations. They will they will

complete the improvements. So in other

words, you're not talking about, oh, the

development comes online, a year or two

or three years later, finally someone

gets improving the traffic,

>> right? And there would be I think there

they have definitely ways to, you know,

enforce those those permit requirements.

>> Thank you. Any uh questions to my

colleagues?

Uh seeing none, I will next invite

Deputy Director Proer uh to give us her

report on housing.

>> Thank you, Chair Dorren, President

Harden, members of council. The proposed

resoning at 7801 Olantage River Road

supports the Columbus housing strategy

by adding critical housing units in a

high demand location and expanding

housing options in an area with

extremely limit limited housing

diversity which limits the options for

housing mobility for existing neighbors

and excludes opportunities for new

neighbors to call this part of Columbus

home. The existing housing in the census

track is 96% owner occupied. 98% single

family homes, 84% of the homes have four

or more bedrooms, and 70% of the

households earn more than $150,000 per

year. The median household income is

more than $198,000 a year, which is 200%

higher than the median income for the

city. Since 2020, the city of Columbus

has added more than nearly 10% more

households. However, in this census

track, there are nearly 6% fewer housing

units and 3% fewer households in this

census track. All of these factors

combined to severely limit the mobility

rate. In this census track, the annual

annual mobility rate between 2023 and

2024 was just 0.39%

compared to a 20% mobility rate uh for

the greater Columbus region. In this

census tract, only 8.4% 4% of residents

have moved since 2020. Compared to the

neighborhood mobility between 2005 and

2010, when 35% of families in the census

tract moved, this indicates an

increasingly stagnant housing market

with little opportunity for new

residents to move into the area and

fewer options for those wanting to

change housing to meet their lifestyle

needs. This housing development is not

only critical to addressing the needs in

this area, but also for the

affordability in the region. As we work

to build sufficient housing units across

our community, the me to meet the

growing housing demand, it is

simultaneously becoming increasingly

hard to build new housing units for

financial reasons. For new housing to be

financially feasible, developers must

carefully balance the rising

construction costs against the projected

revenues to ensure the project is

feasible or it can't or it can't be

built, further slowing down the

construction of housing we need. In

areas like this with high demand and

high home prices, new development is

feasible. Therefore, we need to allow

new for new housing where it can be

built in this region to alleviate the

overall pressure on this system and

ensure regionwide affordability. Happy

to answer any questions.

>> Thank you, Miss Brower. Uh questions

from my council colleagues.

Seeing none. I again I do want to point

out that we do have uh representatives

from Columbus uh power and water here

with us because I know a lot of the

discussion with the community has

revolved around uh questions regarding

storm water the storm water manual and

the process that's uh sort of those

things go through. Um so I will probably

invite the the folks from that

department at some point u to engage

with both council and potentially the

public speakers. But to emphasize um a

project that cannot meet the storm water

requirements of the city of Columbus um

cannot get their permits. So if they

cannot demonstrate that uh they then

have to go back and change the proposal

in order to allow our experts at the

city to say yes that they can meet those

requirements under that new site plan.

Um, and I know there's lots of questions

about why uh those things don't come

first, but uh our system is set up for

folks to come get their zonings or their

variances first before they subsequently

engage in all of those processes for a

variety of reasons. Um, but there are

preliminary steps that are taken with

the department on the front end as they

go through the process. But again, just

from a process standpoint of where we're

at, um, if folks cannot adequately u

meet those requirements, the project

cannot get built in that way. Um, so I

do want to pause and see if any council

colleagues have any questions before I

call the applicants representative.

Seeing none, I would invite Miss Molly.

Welcome back to council.

Okay.

Good evening, members of council,

President Harden, and Chair Dorance.

Thank you very much for the opportunity

to present this evening. My name is

Molly Gwyn, and I am an attorney with

the firm of Ice Miller here representing

the applicant. My address is 250 West

Street, Sweet 700, Columbus, Ohio. Um,

and present with me this evening is our

entire development team, starting first

and foremost with Mr. Eric KTZ with

Story Boards Development. He is the

developer for this project and the owner

of the Northern Parcel that comes before

you tonight. Also present is Mr. Boz

with Whitaker KZ. Mr. Knezz is a

builder. He is the builder we've

selected to construct the homes that

we're going to talk about this evening.

Uh Mason Malcolm, a principal engineer

with Kleers, is also here. Kleiners has

been retained to develop the site plan,

perform the two traffic studies that

have been performed here, and to provide

uh additional guidance and background on

the development standards. Um not

present this evening is Mr. Rob Milligan

with EMH&T uh who we recently retained

in order to have a jurisdictional

delineation done a storm water uh study

done that was performed on site at the

property in March of this year with a

report generated um on April 8th that

I'm going to to get into this evening.

Um and so as noted I I want to talk a

little bit about uh what's around us. Um

and that's the site right there. You'll

see um and to the east we have uh

commercial including the Bristol Senior

Living Center, the Hills Market and two

fuel stations. Uh we do have residential

to the west. Uh to the south we have the

ravines of Worthing Ridge as well as the

Hill and Disease Law Firm. Um and then

to the north we have our our

residential. Um so really we've got kind

of residential uses as well as sort of

your general neighborhood types of uses.

Um, and I would like to just note that

per the recommendation of the land use

plan for this area,

a lot of pictures. Um, the land use plan

does recommend a low density at just

slightly less than four units per acre,

but as noted, um, you can vary that

proposed uses and/or higher density may

merit support if they're compatible with

the adjacent proposed development. Uh,

and we believe that at this point in

time, um, this is in fact consistent

with that land use plan recommendation

as has been noted by city staff. Um, and

so, oh, uh, oh, can I go back to the

beginning? Oh,

I'm getting younger. Um, uh, so these

right here are the elevations. We are

proposing, as noted by city staff, 26

homes that are going to be developed on

private streets. Um, and these designs,

as shown in the elevations, uh, with the

textual commitment for general

conformity with these elevations, uh,

are going to feature high quality design

standards, natural materials, full

cementitious siding, and metal roofs.

Um, and the anticipated price point for

these units is roughly $750 to $800,000,

which we again believe is consistent

with the high-end homes and the high-end

quality of the area. Um, as noted, we've

also committed to an asphalt path on the

property. We've set aside required area

for rightaway dedication to state route

315 at the request of planning staff. Uh

we are going to have privately

maintained common open space. We will be

paying the parkland fee uh in in in lie

of dedication of parkland. Um, we've

also, uh, been in discussions with

Department of Sewers and Drainage to

commit to a payment for downstream INI

remediation to remedy existing sanitary

capacity issues present at the premises.

And most importantly, um, we are

prepared at this point to observe and

respect the riparian corridor based upon

the study that we've had recently

performed here.

Um this plan has evolved substantially

since its inception over two years ago.

Um the initial plan on which the traffic

study is based showed over 40 units and

as noted the access onto Club View uh

north of the site was eliminated. We

reduced the unit count to 34. Had some

other iterations of the plan in between

and now we are down to 26 units. Um and

we would submit that um the feedback

from the neighborhood has been helpful

and has been taken into account in the

changes to the site plan that have

occurred. Uh this project does have

unanimous support from the development

commission. Uh this is just a brief

history of sort of all of the outreach

that we've done here. Uh Mr. KT started

working with uh local stakeholders and

the neighborhood in 24. Uh the traffic

studies were performed in 24. Um, and

then we've had this level of outreach

since 2025,

uh, including, um, an on-site meeting at

at the premises.

Um,

I'd like to just go ahead and and talk a

little bit about, um, complaints we

heard regarding alleged nonobservance of

riparian corridor and non-observance of

the storm water drainage manual of the

city of Columbus. And I want to be very

very clear that the developer is

committed to respecting all regulations

of the city of Columbus and working with

your departments and your professional

planning staff in conjunction with our

professional engineers.

And so we engaged DMH&T to perform an

analysis to determine if a stream

existed on the property and to determine

if riparian corridor would be required

and then subsequently whether the homes

would need to be adjusted. I just want

to note as has been pointed out a final

jurisdictional delineation as well as a

final storm water analysis is not part

of a zoning approval. It is not

typically done at this step in the

process but we've taken this step at

this point and based upon the findings

of the study constructed on site on

March 19th. We have an intermittent

stream here not an ephemeral stream and

there is a difference in what is

required for mediation. Um, the stream

originates offsite and it flows along

roughly the southern boundary of the

property uh along the ravine that's been

shown here. These are the applicable

provisions of the Columbus storm water

and drainage manual that I'm sure that

uh Mr. Fedner can speak to more cogently

than we can. Um, but per our engineers,

we have to maintain 50 ft of riparian

setback, 25 on either side of the stream

and then we have a 15% grade that also

requires observation.

Uh and so we're going to comply with all

of these requirements, including

observing the 50 foot of riparian

corridor. Uh that's 25 on either side of

the stream. The exhibit that has been

prepared allocates all 50 feet onto the

developer's property, but it doesn't

entirely sit with this stream based upon

our fieldwork right on this developer's

property. It runs along the boundary.

Um, and as noted, there are existing

encroachments into this stream corridor

presently with the ravines at Warthing

Ridge condo that likely predate the

storm water management regulations. Um,

so this is the stream right here. This

is where it's shown again. This is based

upon the field study that was

constructed by EMH&T.

Uh, this is the exhibit that was shown

at development commission. I believe

you're going to be seeing this again.

And again, this allocates the riparian

corridor entirely onto the developer

property.

Um, we went ahead and overlaid the

stream based upon the field study onto

our existing plan and we are able to

pull the units out and comply with the

riparian corridor and that's our

intention and that's always been our

intention and that's our obligation here

this evening.

Um, this is the language that's been

referenced. This is the language that

has been added. Uh I will note that to

the extent that there are trees that are

sitting in the riparian corridor and

we're required to observe that those are

the city's trees. Um we'll be required

to do whatever we're instructed with

those trees. Uh that's not going to be

for us to decide. Um and so this is the

language that we worked with planning

staff on and we feel it's a good uh

interim measure. I won't read that to

you because I've been talking for a

while.

Um, one thing I would like to talk about

is the allegation regarding the trees

that are presently present on the

property.

And

we obviously recognize that existing

trees are a benefit to our potential

residents and to our community, but many

of the trees here right now are

diseased, are dead, are a safety hazard,

um, and have been previously requested

to be removed uh, to the property owner

to south. Um, and these are just a few

photos of what the existing condition

looks like. These photos were taken last

month. Um, and as you can see, many of

these trees are far from healthy, mature

trees that would be expected or desirous

to keep.

And perhaps nowhere is this clearer than

this is a photograph again that was

taken just last month. And um, we're all

familiar with the site. When you drive

past it, there is a home. And this is a

photograph of a tree that had fallen on

the house. um some of these trees are

going to have to come down um because it

creates a safety hazard and they're

they're not they're not the the

beautiful things that we all want to see

and that the city deserves.

Uh again, these are the prior plans. We

previously had a duplex type of look. We

previously had 40 units. Now we've got

26 individual town homes.

I also want to note as has already been

noted um that this property is slated

for phase two uh for mixeduse

development. Again, highdensity mixeduse

development including fourstory

buildings is presently slated to go

here. And we think that this fits much

better with the character of the area

and will be of value to to the

community.

The applicant has had two traffic

studies done, one in November and one in

December of 24. Both those studies have

been reviewed by ODOT as well as city

staff as noted. Um, and I just wanted to

call out the AM and PM peak times that

are here. Um, so estimated traffic

generation at AM peak 1 hour is a total

of 15 cars. If you think about that

roughly standing there, uh, it's not not

exactly intensive. Uh, PM peak same time

20 trips. Uh so we have had a study done

and the study has not found that other

improvements are warranted. Um frankly

in order to drive more significant

improvements to this area you would need

higher density and more houses.

Um I don't need that yet. Um, again, we

think that the value of the homes here

are going to be consistent with the

neighboring communities

and we think, as noted by professional

staff that there is most certainly a

need for housing in central Ohio. Um,

and that this housing fills a piece of

the market that uh, while not the kind

of thing that I'm traditionally here

talking about, fits with the character

of the area and will help alleviate some

of the housing shortage in this

corridor.

Um, you know, change is hard. Uh, it's

hard when the field by your property,

it's been a field for a long time,

develops,

but we're here to rely on the

recommendations of your professional

staff and our professional consultants

and the developer who's prepared to

invest $30 million in the development of

this property as to an appropriate what

is an appropriate land use. Uh, as well

as your development commission.

Um, and with that, I will thank you very

much and I'll be prepared to address

rebuttal or answer questions. Sorry.

>> Any questions for Miss Quinn for my

colleagues? So, Miss Quinn, just one

quick question. I I know it's uh just by

a cork of the code, you've been

referring to these as town homes.

>> Um, but in all practical reality, these

are these are detached, you know, single

units. So, you know, how I would

normally refer to a single family house,

but again, in this situation, given the

zoning district under this code that,

you know, just to make clear to my

colleagues that we're talking about, um,

you know, again, basically detached

single family housing, even though that

is practically what is not is actually

referenced from a code standpoint.

>> Yes, that pathway was not exactly

forward for what ex uh we wanted these

to look like from a code standpoint. And

so, yes, they definitely look much more

like single family houses. Some of the

variances that we're going to get into

later speak to the single family

character of the project. They are

detached. They're not attached uh at

this point. And again, that was a change

that was brought about by the feedback

from the development commission. So,

yes, that it really looks, lives, and

feels more like single family homes.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you.

>> Any questions for Miss Quinn?

>> Seeing none, I'll invite you back up

after our public speakers. Uh, as I

mentioned, we have three public speakers

assigned to speak on this ordinance. The

first speaker is Mr. Aaron Newman.

Welcome back to council. Uh, as a

reminder, we'll uh ask folks to state

any relationship they have with the

property and ask folks that try to limit

their remarks to three minutes, but

we'll try to practice Midwestern

politeness as much as we can.

>> Good evening, council members and city

staff. Aaron Newman, 8844 Athetherton

Road, speaking on behalf of the far

northwest Coalition of Columbus. It's

good to see most of you again. Good to

meet some of you for the first time. Uh

coalition is here tonight to reiterate

our board's unanimous recommendation to

disapprove both this resoning

application and the concurrent variances

that would allow the development of 26

high-pric homes on Tangi River Road in

the far northwest. Uh many residents and

members of our board voiced concerns

with this proposed development across

two public hearings and by phone and

email. Uh concerns included the

increased disruption to traffic on Tangi

River Road, the dubious effectiveness

and safety of the right turn only exit,

the increased demand on the utility grid

and wastewater lines as mentioned, and

the destruction of existing trees,

wooded areas, and the fragile waterway

of the bordering ravine. There are also

concerns about the lengthiness of the

phase construction approach, the uh

devastation and ongoing disruption of

such a high density development on such

a uniquely graded site, especially one

on such a precariously vital two-lane

roadway leading right into the city. One

of the overarching concerns, however,

was that the reszoning this property uh

was that resoning this property to the

higher density L12 is fundamentally

inconsistent with the surrounding

properties in the far northwest and

would negatively impact our neighbors

and surrounding properties. The

Northwest Plan recommends lowdensity

residential for the large northern

parcel and states plainly, quote, "A

primary goal of the use plan is to

preserve lowdensity residential

neighborhoods and guide infill

development to be compatible with the

existing development patterns of the

neighborhood. The existing development

pattern of the neighborhood is

lowdensity residential and higher

density development would be flatly

inconsistent with the current use plan.

With respect to city staff, the Columbus

growth strategy does not change the

designation for this parcel. The

southern parcel is a single family

residence zone for office use. And while

the growth strategy recommends potential

smaller mixed use development there, any

such development is a long way away.

Building within the current

recommendation of four units per acre

would allow for redevelopment and

additional homes that are actually

affordable for new families that are

consistent with community standards and

would be welcomed by neighbors.

Moreover, these concurrent applications

would supersede a 2014 council variance

that forms a covenant, a covenant with

the neighbors, requiring that the

southern property remain a single family

residence and maintain all natural

boundaries, a covenant which the current

applicant intends to break. The far

northwest is ready for growth and eager

to welcome new neighbors, but this

proposal is simply not the right fit.

The current I'm sorry, the concurrent

variances sought along with this

resoning also indicate a development

that is too tightly packed onto too

small a site. Low resident low density

residential remains the most appropriate

usage for the property at this time as

we look forward to future redevelopment

of the southern parcel with its

inclusion in the Columbus growth

strategy. Therefore, the board of the

far northwest coalition joins the

impassion neighbors who have remained

engaged in the process throughout.

respectfully request that city council

vote against the resoning application

and concurrent variances and we

encourage the applicant to work with us

on an appropriate plan.

>> Thank you very much.

>> Questions for my council colleagues, Mr.

Newman.

>> So Mr. New I I did want to give you a

chance to respond. So you referenced a

number of times the Northwest plan um

that plan is close to 20 years old. So

when we talk about a modest increase of

of density here going from four to a

little over four here. I just, you know,

talking with your neighbors and

certainly the coalition just when we

talk about the plan being um, you know,

close to two decades, we we know the

growth of Columbus and all the different

areas. I just want to give you an

opportunity, you know, when I see a plan

that is that old. Um, and again, we're

not talking about a significant

departure from it from a density

standpoint. Just want to, you know, you

talk with your neighbors about this.

Just want to give you an opportunity to

respond to that.

>> Sure. Well, it is 20 years old, but it

uh still recommends u low density

residential and again the Columbus

growth strategy does not intend to

change that designation for this parcel.

Uh we have an opportunity, you know, we

had an opportunity to include that in

perhaps make it mixed use as well.

Recommendation like the southern parcel,

but for now and into the near future,

that northern parcel is going to be

zoned low low density residential and we

believe it should stay that way. Still

plenty of room to fill plenty of houses.

>> Council member bro.

>> Yeah. I Hi, welcome back. I have a quick

question just um if you boil it down

brass tax, right? A lot of folks will

come in because they're concerned about

apartments or condos where you know

would have a much higher density than

single family homes. So if they're top

line, what are the main concerns from

the coalition that they would not want

single family homes in this area? Is it

because of the traffic? Is it because of

the rev? Like can you just boil it down

for us of what the main concerns are?

>> Well, there are no concerns with um any

specific type of housing. Uh but when

you get into such dense housing as this,

that's where the concerns come in on

such a small property. So, uh, we'd be

happy to see multif family, single

family, detached houses, as long as

it's, you know, within or near that, you

know, within that four units per acre

designation, uh, we'd be happy to take a

look.

>> So, and this is 26, correct?

>> Total. So, it's 4.43 units per acre.

>> Got it. So if it was less, if it was,

you're saying it doesn't matter if it's

single family homes, but if there were

20, would that be better than 26?

>> If it met the land use plan

recommendation, we would be happy to

consider that. Sure.

>> Okay. Thank you.

>> But this recom this application does not

meet those recommendations.

>> Okay.

Other questions from my colleagues? See

none. Thank you, Mr. Newman.

>> Thank you.

>> Uh our next speaker is Mr. Chris

Vondren,

welcome to council, sir.

Good evening, council. My name is Chris

Fondrin.

I live at 200 East Canawa Avenue,

Columbus, Ohio, here in Clintonville,

over by the school for the blind. Um for

about 30 years now I've been a land

planner, landscape architect. Uh two

different stints in some significant

offices here. One being Kinserman Klein

Gossman, the other one uh MKSK here

which was the merger of two different

firms. But I was asked by Tim Marini,

who is a resident in the area just south

of this development and his community to

look at an evaluation of how this

development plan really sits on the

property. Not to look at densities, not

to look at any of the things related to

zoning, but look at it purely from a uh

a land planning standpoint. A land plan

that hopefully would be sensitive and

responsible.

That's what we try to promote as land

planners and landscape architects. So

everybody I assume has a copy of the

document that I'm going to be referring

to. Right?

>> So what I did was I reached out to my

contacts, gathered some GIS data, topo

soils,

uh vegetation cover, etc. and overlaid

it on the property. Now this property is

not flat. It has about 60 feet change in

elevation from the west down to the east

side. That's about a 12 to 14% slope

across the property. It's not flat. The

land plan that's in place, you would

typically see this signature on a flat

piece of ground. It makes you bring into

qu question some of the uh the practices

behind how to develop this property.

Okay. Um, in comparison, again, the

roadway going up into Worthington Hills

is 9%. We're dealing with a 14 to 12%

slope across this property. Okay. So, if

you look at the topo towards the the

south southern portion of the of of the

development, there are a lot of ganged

close topo lines. That's this ravine

area that we've that is currently there.

Okay. When you look I'm going to speak

more related to building location as it

relates to this ravine. Um when you

look at each one of the footprints

there's about six of them there on the

south side. They are proposed in the

ravine. This is the plan that had been

presented to the community had been

presented in conversations and that's

this is the one that I'm referring to. I

did see a plan in the presentation from

the developer, a modified plan that

speaks to this sensitivity that we need

to pay attention to on the south side.

So, we've already started to see a

modified plan to reflect the concerns of

the surrounding community.

Um, I was asked to also create some in

the next exhibits some cross-sections to

show where the bottom of the ravine

would be, the current slopes of of the

property.

>> I you can have a couple more rants.

>> Okay, thank you very much. And so this

area is by criteria standpoints based

upon the storm water manual an area that

would be considered for a stream

corridor protection zone. So, I'm going

to go towards the last page to speed

this up.

There is a hatched area.

It would be this page right here,

the very last page. Okay? Again, I'm not

getting to the trees that are mature

trees that are 102 years old that I

think are valuable, but as it relates to

this area, there is a minimum protection

zone based upon the calculations that

storm water uh engineers will go

through. This meets the minimum based

upon the catchment area and the water

that flows through this. So already in

this plan, which the red boxes suggest a

modification to the plan, we started to

see that in the last presentation.

That's the first time I think anybody

I've seen that or anybody in the

community has seen an adjustment to the

plan already. So with that being said,

I'll I'll I'll wrap it up with any

questions.

>> Sure. Uh any questions, my colleagues?

>> Okay. See none. Thank you.

>> Thank you very much. Uh, our final

speaker on this ordinance is Mr. Tim

Reinie, who is uh, I believe joining us

virtually. Do we have him, Mark?

>> Mr. Reinie, can you hear us?

>> Yes, sir. Thank you.

>> Floor is yours, sir.

>> Thank you,

council members and city staff. Thank

you for having me. My name is Tim Rinie.

I live at 7-Eleven Old Oak Trace, which

is in the um community right across the

ravine that Chris was just speaking

about. Uh my background is I had a

46-year career as a registered architect

and a residential real estate developer.

So, I'm extremely familiar with um what

is being proposed here. And I think it's

important for me to say that um our

neighborhood is not opposed to this site

being developed. We're not opposed to

a lot of what Mr. KTZ has um suggested.

I will tell you that I'm overjoyed that

there's already been a revision in the

site plan this evening because we we

have been pointing that out for months

that there are homes originally in the

ravine down by the stream that if you

thumb through Chris's uh slideshow in

your hand, you'll see where that is. Um,

I'm kind of throwing out my my

prepared remarks to simply say that if

you drive from

uh Ohio State north on 315 to Delaware,

you are surrounded by the Tangi River

Valley, the scenic Tangi River that this

uh intermittent stream flows into.

Um, you will also notice organic site

design the entire way from just south of

Henderson Road all the way up into

Delaware. And that is the caliber

that our community is, our our little

10-unit condo community. That's the

caliber of development that Worthington

Hills is. That's the caliber and the

characteristic of design up and down the

scenic byway of Tangi River Road. That

is what we have been asking

that would please be adhered to.

um taking this slope site, which I

respect is going to be a tough design to

to get to work, but terracing it off

into two big flat areas and lining it

with

pretty much identical homes, identical

setbacks the entire way up and down is

not a characteristic of our entire area.

If Mr. Kettz could could look at that, I

I'm glad he's finally seeing the light

that

he shouldn't be building in a 30-ft deep

ravine.

Um I I hope that we could get things

like the the limitation text tightened

up a little bit. Uh there's a lot of

vague ambiguous information there that

really does not say anything about the

the quality and the commitment of the

site planning on this project. I will

say one other thing.

Our community has raised a lot of issues

about the trees on this site. And indeed

in the ravine, there's some pretty sadl

looking trees. But when you have a

developer coming in that's literally

saying their their back wall of their

home is going to be just a few feet from

a stream, it it gets pretty unnerving.

If you look at the mature trees that are

at the crest of the ravine, there are

some specimen trees there.

The development commission encouraged

Mr. Kettes to keep a buffer between our

properties.

The the number one buffer that could be

should be kept are the trees at the

crest of the ravine. They are healthy.

They are significant. They are specimen

trees and as much organic design as

could please be incorporated into this

project, we would appreciate it. Uh my

original request tonight was that this

be tabled because

there needs to be more guidelines. I

will stick with that. If if you read the

memo that I submitted to the the council

members, I mentioned and even gave some

uh sample language. Not that I was

trying to say that's what the additional

limitation text should say, but right

now there's very little guidelines for

this development. Thank you very much

for hearing me and uh I appreciate your

time. Thank you, Mr. Reinie. Any

questions from my council colleagues for

the speaker? Thank you. I will invite

the applicants representative, Miss

Gwen, back if she wants to have any

rebuttal with any of the public comment.

Good evening. Uh I won't belabor the

point on this but I'll just note that we

had fieldwork done to identify where

this stream is and then EMH&T provided

that fieldwork I believe to the city as

well as to Kleers who was then able to

overlay the stream on the CAD file and

orient the units. It's not a new site

plan. It just shows how the existing

site plan can can respect with the same

number of units and all of the same

variances that are required how the

existing plan uh can be respectful of

that riparian corridor. Um and and

again, you know, uh

this developer's efforts to engage with

the neighborhood are are quite well

documented. Um and it's not a matter of

us just now seeing the light on a

jurisdictional delineation. That is

typically not done at this phase of the

process, but it has been done at this

point. Um the elevations that are shown

uh are a result of two development

commission meetings and adjustments that

were proposed subsequent to those two

development commission meetings and as

noted have the support um of of city

planning staff for that. So, um, again,

uh, this is someone who has worked very

very hard to be responsive to the

concerns of of the neighborhood. And

I'll just note that it's disappointing

the continued ad hominemum attacks

against the developer for doing things

in accordance with the city's direction

and the development commissions. Thank

you.

>> Thank you, Miss Quinn. Any questions?

Council member White. Miss Quinn, I

think Council Member White has a

question for you.

>> You're good. And I don't have a

question. I do appreciate the back and

forth that has been done between the

neighbors and developers. When I heard

about this project from some of the

neighbors, they expressed concerns

regarding the number of units, the type

of units that would be there, and

changes were made. And then we talked

about the stream quarter protection

zone, and it looks like again changes

have been made to kind of meet the needs

of the residents. Um, so my vote, my no

vote this evening has nothing to do with

that. I think we have worked, you have

worked tremendously hard to kind of

bring a proposal together that that kind

of makes sense on that land. My

hesitation and my concern is that

intersection of Tangi River Road and

315. It is a nightmare. I disagree with

ODOT's thinking that a lefthand turn

lane is gonna make any sense at all when

it's constantly backed up all the time.

So, I appreciate the work of the

developer. I applaud him for continuing

to bring the right people to the table.

That was also something that I heard in

the very beginning. He didn't have the

right people. He's never done this

before. This isn't going to work. But it

has shown through just your constant uh

back and forth with the community that

you wanted to bring forth a plan that

took their feedback into consideration

to find something that was going to be

most workable. So I do appreciate that.

>> Thank you very much. And

>> chair I do have a quick question. Um

can you some someone I don't know the

appropriate person but at this juncture

you you mentioned this a little bit

before when we talked about this uh

storm stewer etc. So those protections

along the ravine at which point are

those do we ensure that those are

enforced in the site plan and who does

that enforcement?

>> So um Misswin and then I can certainly

throw it to some of our folks in

planning as well but Miss Gwen do you

want to speak to that? uh we will have

to submit a CC plan that identifies

after we get through uh hopefully if

we're successful this evening and we get

through zoning um we would final

engineer the site we would submit a

final site compliance plan because this

is NAR 12 we would then submit our storm

water CC plans which would be reviewed

um and it would note the the riparian

corridor and the slope that's in there

that's an an extra item that we're

required to observe in this area given

the 15% grade where the ravine sits. Uh

and again um we would submit our uh

storm water delineation at that time for

review uh by the Army Corps of Engineers

as well as city planning staff.

>> Council member, if I can I think some of

the confusion that certainly has I think

contributed to some of the back and

forth with the community and the

applicant has been around was this in

fact a stream. Um these are fun land use

questions you end up getting into and

originally there was a contention

certainly um that there was a question

around whether or not this was in fact a

stream um due to its intermittent times

where it runs or doesn't run. So once um

there was a a designation that it was in

fact a stream that's when the riparian

corridor requirements kick in. So um

that's where I think there was some very

healthy back and forth between the

applicant and and the community about

well what are you going to do about

this? Um there are many many things in

our community that we don't realize are

in fact streams until again the

engineers look at them and make a

designation. In this case uh I think

we'd be in a very different place right

now if there was still dispute about

whether or not that was in fact

classified as a stream. No one here at

at this point is in fact arguing about

that. So the the the buffer that exists

is just the buffer that that comes. So

while other things from the site plan

can change since that has been

designated as a stream at this point

that buffer is the buffer. It that

cannot change. uh throughout the process

at this point.

>> I'm just wondering when I look at, you

know, I'm a visual person. When I look

at other places where we have built

homes near ravines up near

Worththington, Clintonville, etc. I

mean, I'm my assumption is we've taken

these things into account. I mean, even

in, you know, Clintonville, we actually

have a path that goes through so that

people can use it and come come down

from their homes, etc. So, I'm just

wondering I mean I hear from some of our

experts that live in the area that you

know you know some of their concerns

which I guess I'm also just trying to

boil down what the concerns are of the

community and what the push back is and

just it seems that we're addressing them

along the way. We haven't gotten quite

to traffic yet but it seems that we are

addressing some of those protections

along what is a ravine or stream etc.

Um, and then I know the density is maybe

pushing it a little bit for folks, but

I'm I guess I'm I'm just trying to also

understand what all the other challenges

might be and at what point do we look at

those and it seems that we're course

correcting on some.

>> Yeah.

>> And just to address that, there is right

now encroachment into that riparian

corridor, I believe, with the ravines at

Warthing Ridge. Some of those homes are

in the area that's designated. Um

there's also reference in the materials

that have been provided that this is an

ephemeral stream. Uh our study says it's

an intermittent stream and that requires

slightly different uh mitigation that is

required. And then finally um there is a

variance process. It's not a BCA

variance. It's not a council variance.

There is a variance process in order to

allow for encroachment within the

riparian corridor that's handled uh at

an administrative level again with

professional planning staff. So that

might be why uh you're seeing some of

that. But at this point in time, it is

the applicant's intention to just comply

with the requirements of the storm water

drainage manual in terms of the

placement of those homes. Um certainly.

And my last question to our last

speaker's point around the mature trees

and the buffer, is it what is the

intention of the developer in terms of

preservation of mature trees in the

places where we potentially can?

>> What does that look like? And is there a

plan to plant more tree? What is that?

>> Certainly to the extent that trees are

healthy and not unsafe, we would do

everything we can to preserve those

trees. Uh they're about and and they're

not where the houses need to go. Uh

there is a commitment in the text right

now that speaks to the obligation to

preserve them one to one. Um, I'll just

note that the proposal for language in

the limitation text that was submitted

on Friday and redone,

um, proposed that trees of 24 in

diameter at breast height or greater,

and all trees within 25 ft of the ravine

crest, which again are clearly in the

storm water protection zone and would

not be for us to determine, uh, shall be

presumptively preserved and, if approved

for removal, replaced at a 3:1 caliber

to inch ratio. ratio. Um that is

obviously a very

extensive standard that I have never

seen anywhere else. So our our intention

is to replace one to one and certainly

preserve mature healthy trees where we

can. They're a value to our community.

They're a value to our residents. Uh and

it doesn't mean we're not going to plant

other trees as well. But we we have some

concerns with the current state of them

and some of them are going to have to

come down. We don't want to make blanket

commitments about tree preservation and

then not be able to honor them.

>> Sure. Yeah. Thank you.

>> Okay.

>> Thank you, Miss Gwen. Any other

questions for my colleagues? Seen them.

Thank you. Um, you know, I had the

opportunity to meet with some of the

neighbors on this this u piece of

legislation uh a number of months ago. I

think obviously we've seen tonight a

number of different changes to the plan.

I think we've also talked a lot about

what comes after zoning. You know,

fundamentally before council is a land

use question. Some of the administrative

processes whether it's storm water or

other things happen beyond you this

body. Uh, you know, it's somewhat ironic

that normal we're down here when we have

lots of opposition to a zoning. It's

oftentimes around large multif family

projects. You know, it's sort of

interesting here tonight. We have 26

what functionally are single family

houses um with some significant

opposition and certainly I think many of

my colleagues have heard from folks and

engaged with folks I think meaningfully

throughout this process as we've seen

the applicant make what I think are

meaningful changes uh to this proposal.

Uh that said, this is certainly an area

that, you know, could use more housing

according to Director Proer's report.

Certainly an area in which we're seeing

a modest increase in in density. Uh I,

you know, respect my colleagues concerns

around the traffic. But I'm not a

traffic engineer. Neither is he. And

certainly, you know, when we think about

how do we have these administrative

processes in place to ensure that um

these things are handled, I I believe

the system that is in place should

provide the benefit that is necessary to

help again to account for what is a

small increase in density. Uh Columbus

is growing. It's going to continue to

grow. Uh that's going to mean more

traffic no matter what. It's a question

of how do we approach that and how do

our processes help to address that. Uh

so in my opinion while you know I I

certainly understand folks within that

area would like to see more out of the

applicant at this point I think the

applicant has demonstrated good faith

over and over and over again in this

instance and you know at some point you

know they uh deserve an answer from the

body about whether or not the proposal

that is in front of us um is a policy

choice that this body would like to make

and I think at this point they've

demonstrated um that they have put

together a plan um that justifies um

this body's consideration. So that at

this point I move to amend and submit to

the clerk by voice.

>> Clerk, please call the role.

>> Bankston,

>> yes.

>> Barrosa Deodia,

>> yes.

>> Dorren,

>> yes.

>> Remy,

>> yes.

>> Ross,

>> yes.

>> White,

>> no.

>> President Harden,

>> yes. Amended.

>> Thank you. Next move for passage as

amended.

>> Second.

>> Cler, please call the role by voice.

>> Bankston,

>> yes.

>> Barosa Padilla,

>> yes.

>> Dorren,

>> yes.

>> Remy,

>> yes. Ross

>> White,

>> no.

>> President Harden,

>> yes. Passed.

>> Thank you. Next, we have ordinance

1294-26 reszone 3600 Park Mill Run Road

being 12.56 plus acres located in the

northwest corner of Spring Mill Drive

and Fisher Bowling Bar from CPD

commercial plan development district to

CPD commercial plan development

district. Site consists of one parcel

developed a big box home improvement

retailer and the requested resoning will

incorporate an updated development text

and site plan demonstrating accessory

outdoor storage. A code modification to

require require parking from 442 spots

to 393 spots is included in the text. A

concurrent council variance will uh

considered with this piece of

legislation later on agenda. Proposal is

approved from city staff development

commission and the west sciota area

commission question comments. See and

move for passage.

>> Please call the role.

>> Thanks Timberia. Dors Remy Ross vice

president Harden

>> passed.

>> Thank you. Next we move into our

variances portion of our agenda. First

we have ordinance number 0291-2026

to grant a variance provision section

3312.27 parking setback line 3333.18

building lines and 3332.255 Primary yard

of the Columbus District property

located at 2100 Harder Road to allow

reduced development standards in the for

apartment complex and R1 apartment

residential district. Again uh at the

applicant's request I move to postpone

this ordinance to the June 8th zoning

committee agenda. like please call the

role.

>> Banks Rosa de Padilla, Dorren, Remy

Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Thank you. And please let the B reflect

that Jennifer Delass and Kevin Craig

will have their speaker slips honored at

that meeting. Uh next we have ordinance

number uh 1031-2026

to grant advance provisions of section

3370.05 permitted use of the Columbus

city codes for the property located 1905

Jetway Boulevard to allow a recreational

facility in the LM limited manufacturing

district. Site consists of one parcel

developed with two warehouses and the

requested council of variance will allow

a recreational facility within the

existing building and council of

variance is required because the

limitation text does not allow for

recreation facilities. Uh the proposal

is approved from city staff and the

northeast area commission. Any questions

or comments? Seeing none, I first move

to accept the entire staff report into

evidence as an exhibit.

>> Cler please call the role.

>> Bankston Barosa de Padilla Dors Remy

Ross vice president Harden

>> accept it.

>> Thank you. I next move to adopt the fine

staff as the finance of councel.

>> Cler please call the role. Banks Rosa de

Padilla Dors Remy Ross Vice President

Harden

>> adopt it.

>> Thank you. And fin move for passage.

Second clerk.

>> Please call the role.

>> Banks Rosa de Padilla Dors Remy Ross

Vice President Harden

>> pass.

>> Thank you. Next we have ordinance number

1036-2026

a grand variance of provisional section

333.025

AR 12 ARLD and AR AR1 apartment

residential uses 333.41HIG 41HIG

standards of the Columbus city codes for

property located at 708 and 709 Tanger

River Road to allow reduced development

standards for the town houses in the

LR12 limited apartment residential

district. Uh this is a concurrent

variance to the resoning we just

considered u for a proposed development

of 26 individually platted town houses.

A this variance request includes a used

a variance to reduce the minimum number

of town homes in a row from 3 to one and

a development standard variance to allow

individually platted townhouse town

houses on private streets to reduce the

front building line and reduce the side

yard setback. Proposal approved from

city staff and a disapproval from the

civic association the area and again a

reminder there's no area commission that

covers this section of the city. Uh due

to the disapproval, we'll once again

hear hear from the department building

zoning service representative to present

a staff report on the variances only.

Mr. Dietrich, floor is yours.

Chair Dorren, President Hard and members

of council, the council vance request

before you includes a use variance to

reduce the minimum number of town homes

in a row from three units to one unit

and includes development standards to

allow individually plotted town houses

on private streets and to reduce the

front building line and sideyard

setbacks. Uh staff concurs with the

applicant's analysis of the seven

practical difficulties in achieving the

proposed development and supports the

requested variances. Staff note that the

provided building elevations, site

design, and commitments to preserve

mature trees are all consistent with the

Columbus growth strategies design policy

and we recommend approval.

>> Thank you, Mr. Dietrich. Uh question

with my colleagues for the department at

this time. I would like to invite the

applicants represented forward. Um, and

MissWim, since this is the variance, I

will swear you in when you get to the

podium. And just as a reminder for the

other public speaker sign speak on this

ordinance, uh, since this is a variance

request and council sitting in a quasi

uh, judicial capacity, I will be

swearing in everyone when they give

testimony. Uh, do you swear affirm the

testimony you're about to give shall be

the truth, nothing but the truth, as you

shall answer under pains of penalty of

perjury. So, please say I do.

>> I do.

>> Floor is yours, Miss.

>> Thank you. Uh, yeah, nice to see

everyone again. Um so I um the first

variance that is before us this evening

is to section 3333.41H.

Um that provision of the code requires

that each townhouse uh shall have a

minimum of 15 ft of frontage on a

dedicated public street and the simplest

varian uh way to explain this is we have

private streets here and so we just need

a variance from this. Um and we would

submit that this variance will not

substantially impact the surrounding

properties. The surrounding properties

are largely residential and neighborhood

commercial in nature. Um it is

consistent we believe with most of the

surrounding uses uh and will allow for

our kind of highquality fe simple town

homes. We don't believe it will

substantially alter the character of the

neighborhood. Uh again we're consistent

with residential residential here. Uh

will not impact the delivery of

governmental services. Um if anything it

will be hopefully helpful to service

impact because these are private streets

that will be required to be maintained

by the HOA. Um and design standards will

not be negatively impacted by the

presence of this variance. Uh so that's

the first variance. I'll then address

the next one. I need to create a record

on this. So um the next variance um

again is to code section 3333.025.

Um and this is for in the uh AR12 which

is what we are going to requiring um

townhouse development with no more than

eight in a row and no less than three in

a row. We do have kind of a fee simple

standalone residential town home

product. Um and uh it's a little bit of

a different product than the code

recognizes right now. And so we're

looking for a variance there to allow

for one unit in a row, one town home at

a time. Um and again we would submit

that this is consistent more consistent

probably than attached town homes with

the surrounding kind of character of the

area. Um it again allows for the town

homes to be developed at at kind of the

the price point that we're looking at.

Will not substantially alter the

character of the neighborhood. Uh they

are intended to be sold. They are

intended to be for sale product. Um will

not impact the delivery of governmental

services. uh and design standards will

not be negatively impacted.

Um the next variance that we have is uh

to the lot line and that's a variance to

code section 3333.41J.

Um and we've got 25 ft for the build

line from the front lot line

irrespective of the orientation from the

building. We are requesting a modest

variance to that. Um we would like it to

be 20 ft. Uh we would submit that this

is not substantial and we would submit

again that it allows us to slightly

increase the density on the property. Uh

does not substantially impact delivery

of governmental services, does not alter

the character of the surrounding

neighborhood. Um and design standards

will not be negatively impacted. Uh it

also will allow for us to pull those

houses forward a little bit out of that

that ravine area. Um and then finally,

uh variance to section 3333.41i.

Um we would like to vary the sideyard

setbacks to 5- foot side yards. This is

consistent with the residential

development standards for

straightforward residential. It is what

is required. Um technically for any end

unit in here in a town home development,

it's 7 and 1/2 ft. But you could have

three in a row that were connected that

are zero lot line that have no sideyard

setback between buildings. Um, and

again, this is being done to allow for a

type of housing of product that maybe

isn't quite exactly reflected in the

code with the town homes. And so again,

we would submit that it will not

substantially alter the character of the

neighborhood. It will allow for the look

of the product that we want, the look of

the houses that we want, will not impact

the delivery of governmental services.

This is consistent with fire code

requirements. It's done on residential

uh all of the time and is consistent

with a more residential look. Um and uh

it will not negatively impact the look

of the other properties. And so those

are the four council variances that are

submitted concurrently with this design

application. I'm happy to answer any

questions.

>> Any questions for my colleagues for the

applicants to represent?

>> Seeing none, uh we can invite you back

after uh public speakers.

>> Okay.

>> As I mentioned, we have three public

speakers signed to speak on this

variance. Um I will call those speakers

in order that the slips are received.

First, we have Mr. Paul Peterson.

Mr. Peterson, welcome to council. Again,

just a reminder, I'll swear everyone in

at the podium.

>> Patterson, I'm sorry.

Uh, do you swear affirm that testimony

have to give up the truth, nothing but

the truth, as ye shall answer under

pains of penalty perjury? If so, please

say I do.

>> I do.

>> Floor is yours, sir.

>> Very good. Thank you. Thank you,

Councilman. Thank you, members. My name

is Paul Patterson. I live at 771 Old Oak

Trace, which ab butts the property in

question. More than 40 years ago, a

well-known central Ohio developer, Bob

Webb, and his company built 10 homes on

a ridge bounded by two ravines, one on

each side, nestled within an old growth

forest as part of Worthington Hills. He

understood that the natural beauty of

the forest and the ravines would enhance

the value and character of the homes

built there. As the street name might

suggest to you, the community was

developed among dozens of oak trees that

are well over 100 to 200 years old and

still standing today. He built the

houses in and around them. My property

adjoins the property in question. The

proposed development plan as it exists

today would dramatically alter the

environment we have known for decades.

In its current form, the old growth

forest on the property in question would

largely be eliminated in contradiction

to the Columbus urban forestry master

plan, replacing a naturally wooded

ravine or excuse me, naturally wooded

view with an unnecessarily cramped

housing complex. Meanwhile, the new

development would continue to benefit

from the views of the old growth forest

on our side of the ravine. How is that

fair? How is that consistent with

responsible development that should seek

to integrate respect, excuse me, to

integrate respectfully into a

neighborhood that has existed since the

1960s?

The the request zoning relief from

established developments setback

standards is clearly intended to

increase dense, excuse me, increase

development density.

This increases in density will

inevitably impact the character of our

adjacent community and the aesthetics

that residents have valued and become

accustomed to over many decades.

Maintaining the current standards

between the home and structures

preserves both our quality of quality of

life and the environment character

environmental character that makes the

area unique. I'm sorry, I'm trying to

read through glasses and I can't.

Support for these variances would erode

what has taken generations to create.

I urge you to consider voting no for

these variances.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you, sir. Any questions from my

colleagues?

>> Thank you.

>> Um the next speaker to come for councel

is Mr. Brian Hunt. Mr. Hunt, welcome

back.

>> I'll swear you in here in a second.

Do you uh swear affirm the testimony

you're about to give sh the truth

nothing but the truth as you shall

answer under pains of penalty of

perjury. If so, please say I do.

>> I do.

>> Floor is yours, sir.

>> Thank you.

>> Good evening, members of council. My

name is Brian Hunt and I'm appearing on

behalf of the ravines at Worththing

Ridge condominium association which has

comprised the property owners adjacent

to the property who will be directly

affected by this development. Before I

get into my prepared remarks, I'd just

like to briefly respond to a statement

earlier this evening that neighbors have

attacked the developer. I haven't heard

any personal attacks tonight. I've heard

genuine, reasonable concerns about the

way that this development will impact

the neighboring property owners, and I

think comments like that are neither

warranted or accurate in this case. That

said, we respectfully urge this council

to deny the requested variances for

multiple reasons. Before city council

may grant a variance, it must find that

the applicant has demonstrated practical

difficulties under the seven factor test

established by the Ohio Supreme Court in

the case of Duncan v. Village of

Middlefield, as well as the standards

codified in section 3307.10

of the Columbus Code of Ordinances. Many

of those factors weigh decisively

against the approval in this case.

First, the property can recognize a

reasonable return without the variances.

The applicant has claimed that no

reasonable return is possible without

the variances. Yet, the site currently

operates as a realtor's office in a

single family dwelling, and thus the

property plainly yields a current

return. Today, any hardship here is

self-created, and the inability to

develop without variances flows from the

applicant's chosen site configuration,

not from any inherent characteristic of

the land that makes code compliant

development impossible. Second, the

variances are substantial. The applicant

claims the variances are not. Yet in a

single application, the applicant seeks

to eliminate public street frontage for

all 26 proposed lots, reduce sideyard

setbacks from 7 1/2 to 5 ft on every

lot, and cut front building lines from

25 ft to as little as 11 ft. These are

not minor adjustments. Multiple

simultaneous variances applied to every

lot in the 26 development are by any

reasonable measure substantial.

Third, the neighborhood characteristics

will be altered by the variances. This

site is surrounded on three sides by

single family dwellings. Those

neighborhoods are defined by public

streets, meaningful front yards,

sideyard separation, and lower density.

The variances would strip all of those

features from this development and allow

private streets with no public access,

setbacks as shallow as 11 ft, a five

foot sideyard on every lot, and higher

density. It is those dimensional

departures that create a risk of

detriment to adjoining owners and the

applicant has not shown otherwise.

Fourth, the variances do circumvent the

code's purpose. The public street

requirement ensures emergency access and

municipal services. The setback

standards protect light, air, and

neighbors reasonable privacy

expectations. And waving all of these

standards simultaneously across an

entire development is not a variance

from practical difficulties.

Nor is it in line with the code. It is a

customtailored zoning district created

for one applicant's preferred design.

Thus, the practical difficulties are

self-imposed.

Just to be clear and to reiterate what's

been said already, my client and its

members do not oppose residential use or

redevelopment of the site. We do however

take issue with the elimination of the

standards that Ohio law and the Columbus

code require a showing of genuine

practical difficulty to wave and

respectfully that showing has not been

made. Therefore, we ask the council deny

the requested variances at this time and

I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank

you.

>> Thank you, Mr. Hunt. Questions from

council members.

>> Thank you.

>> Uh our final speaker to come for

council, Mr. Rob Miller.

Council, sir, and I will swear you into

the podium.

>> Chair, if we have a question about when

Well, should we just wait till after and

then we'll go back? Yeah, we'll either

either ask you to direct question to the

department or the applicant's

representative. Mr. Miller, raise your

rating. Do you swear affirm the

testimony I've been about to give shall

be the truth, nothing but the truth, as

you shall answer under pens of penalty

perjury? If so, please say I do.

>> I do.

>> Floor is yours, sir.

>> Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chair

Dorren, Council President uh Harden, and

the council members for uh the

opportunity to address this situation.

My name is Robert Miller, owner at 718

Old Oak Trace, uh which is in the

ravines at Worththing Ridge, just uh

boring the south of that ravine. And

I'll be very uh practical about you've

heard lots of things today and and just

to reiterate, we are not opposed and

have never suggested to be opposed to

development of the property. It is a

wonderful property that has uh beautiful

characteristics and one of them is the

ravine. And so I have just very

practical concern about the ravine and

the building at the ravine because we've

been consistent on that feedback that

that's something that actually brings

tremendous asset and value to our

properties. And so that's not only just

the visual, but I want to also talk

about the fact that you're going to have

those buildings that are going to be

sunk down for walkout in that area. So

you're going to have uh blasting and and

destruction of the ravine. So setback is

important in that time on that. So as I

was reading through this and preparing a

key aspect for this council in

authorizing any variance, the city

council will first determine that such

variance will not and there's a number

of things there unreasonably diminish or

impair established property values. I'm

very concerned that this will have a

problem with our property values because

of the potential for the change in

drainage that's going on in there. The

undermining of our foundation, our road

driveway that accesses that has all of

that is right on top of the uh on the

side of the ravine. So to lose any of

those types of things would have truly

detrimental elements of it. If you do

vote for the variance, I also noted that

the council may impose such requirements

conditions regarding the development. So

I would hope that in that that

conditions and requirements around that

ravine that protect the value that we

see as we look out onto that. And so

it's tremendously important to the asset

and the value not only of our property

but of the development's property to

retain the quality of that ravine. So I

look for you and ask you to vote against

the the variance that's requested here

before more work can be done to do that.

So thank you very much.

>> Thank you Mr. Miller. Any questions for

Miss my colleagues?

Seeing none, I would invite Miss Gwyn

back up for any additional comments. And

council member, I don't know if you have

a question directly for Miss Gwyn or for

the department. Thank you.

>> Miss I'm going to have you make any

comments you like. Then I know council

member Barrosa David has at least one

question for you.

>> I'd just like to briefly address some of

the Duncan factors quickly. Um in terms

of a reasonable return, um there is a

need to have a few more units on this

property to to make to make this work.

And so um while the property is

presently vacant and there is on the

southern parcel of a commercial real

estate office, for our purposes, we need

these variances to allow this to have a

reasonable return. Um there are existing

conditions that make this property

difficult and impose a practical

difficulty. These are not self-created

by the applicant. The first is the

ravine that we've discussed extensively

here and frankly the reduction in the

front yard setback is going to allow us

to pull those houses even further out of

the ravine. So it will serve the purpose

um of making this more aesthetically

pleasing development. This property also

has a very significant grade. I believe

it is approximately 70%. Um, I'll let

No. Okay. It's I'll let our engineer

speak to the to the grade in support of

this, but there is a significant grade

that's at the property. Um, and there's

a a switchback that's required for the

existing drive. And that dictates not

only the front yard setbacks that need

to be reduced, but also the sideyard

setbacks that again are just tightened

up because these are all considered end

units. Uh, and again, we think this

actually serves the spirit and intent of

the zoning ordinance because these

variances help make it more consistent

with single family dwelling units. Um,

and so it it's more consistent with the

neighboring properties. It's more

consistent with uh what's around it and

it allows us to respect the difficult

conditions on the site all while frankly

helping with delivery of governmental

services given that these are private

roads. And so answer your question.

Thank you.

>> Um, again, this is just kind of the look

and feel of the community. They're

proposed to be private streets at this

point. Um, it started out as an AR. It

is an ARLD. Uh, private streets are

required in an ARLD. I believe they're

set forth in the code. Uh, and so

private streets consistent with the ARLD

code, but we'd like to be able to do fee

simple lots, platted lots, and that's

the reason for the variance. So,

>> thank you. Thank you.

>> Any other questions from council

members?

>> Thank you, Miss Good.

>> Thank you. Um, so again, I think as it's

been stated a number of times by by

folks for and against this proposal,

this is an incredibly unique property.

Uh, whenever we see properties that are

this unusual, uh, we tend to see more

variance requests simply to try and make

uh, projects fit and work. Uh, you know,

I've had a chance to review the staff

reports um, and certainly appreciate all

the testimony that's been provided here

tonight. I do believe the applicant has

met their burden under the Duncan

factors in order to justify these

hardships. Um so therefore I I move to

accept the entire separate into evidence

as exhibit by voice.

>> Bankston

Padilla

>> Dorens.

>> Yes.

>> Remy

>> Ross

>> White.

>> President Harden.

>> Yes.

>> Thank you. Next move to adopt the fin

staffs the fines of councel by voice.

Please call the ro.

>> Bankston.

>> Yes.

>> Barrosa de podia.

>> Yes.

>> Dorance.

>> Yes.

>> Remy.

>> Yes.

>> Ross.

>> W.

>> President Harden.

>> Yes.

>> Thank you. I finally move for passage by

voice.

>> Please call the

>> Bankston.

>> Barosa de Padilla.

>> Dorren.

>> Yes.

>> Remy.

>> Yes.

>> Ross.

>> W.

President Harden.

>> Thank you. Next we have ordinance

1295-226 grand variance provisions of

section 33563 C4 per permitted uses

3361.02

permitted use of the Columbus DOS for

properly located at 3600 Park Mill Run

Drive to allow for accessory outdoor

storage in the CPD commercial plan

development district. This is a

concurrent variance to a reszoning

ordinance we heard tonight earlier in

our agenda. The request that council

variance will allow accessory storage

uses as part of a home improvement

retail development. Council variance is

required because the current zoning

district does not allow outdoor storage.

The approval the proposal is approved

from city staff and the west side area

commission. I first move to accept the

entire staff report and do evidence as

an exhibit.

Please call the

>> Bankston Barrosa de Padilla Dorance Remy

Ross President Hart.

>> Accept it.

>> Thank you. Next move to adopt the fine

staff as council.

>> Clerk please call the role.

>> Bankston Barrosa de Padilla Dorance Ros

sorry Dorrence Remy Ross vice president

Harden.

>> Adopt it. Thank you. Finally move for

passage or

>> please call the role.

>> Bank Simber Rosa de Padilla Dorne Remy

Ross Weiss President Harden

>> passed.

>> Thank you. Next we have ordinance

1346-2026

to grant a variance provision section

3367.01 M2 manufacturing district 331

point uh 3312.49 C required parking this

code for property located at 350

McCormack Boulevard to allow accessory

eating, drinking and retail use to

reduce parking in the N2 manufacturing

district. site consists of one parcel

developed with a mix of recreational

warehousing and manufacturing uses and

the council variance will allow 2,179

square feet of accessory eating,

drinking and retail space within an

existing recreation facility. The

council variance required because the

current zoning district does not allow

eating and drinking or retail uses.

Advance to reduce require parking from

226 to 201 is also included in the

request proposal as approved from city

staff and the far east area commission.

Uh we had one public speaker on this

ordinance, Mr. Bill Taylor, but that

speaker decided to rescend their wish to

speak at this committee hearing.

Therefore, I first move to accept the

entire staff report into evidence as an

exhibit.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Banks Barosa Deodia, Dorren, Remy, Ross,

White, President Harden.

>> Accept it.

>> I move to adopt the fiance of staff as

defiance of council. Cler, please call

the role.

>> Bankston, Barosa de Padilla, Dorren,

Remy, Ross, White, President Harden.

>> Adopted.

>> Finally, move for passage.

>> Cler, please call the role. Banks Timber

Rosa Padilla Dorren Remy Ross Vice

President Harden

>> pass and finally we have ordinance

1350-2026 grant a variance provision

section 3332.035

R3 residential district 331249C require

parking in 3321.05 D2 vision clearance

in 333 2.5 A4 acre just with

requirements 333 2.13 R3 area district

requirements 333 2.18D basic computing

area 333 2.21 building lines 333 2.25 25

A3 required side yards and 333 2.27 rear

yard of the Columbus City Coast for

property located at 574-576

Kelton Avenue to allow two unit dwelling

with reduced development standards in

the R3 residential district. Site

consists of one undeveloped parcel and

the requested council variance will

allow the site to be developed with a

twounit dwelling. A council variance

required because the current district

prohibits two twounit dwellings. A

variance required parking, vision

clearance, lot width, lot area, lot

coverage, building setback, sideyard,

and rear yard are also included in this

request. Proposal approved from city

staff and the near east area commission.

First move to accept the entire sty

evidence as an exhibit.

>> Click please call the row.

>> Bank Rosa de Padilla Dors Remy Ross,

Vice President Harden.

>> Accept it.

>> Thank you. And next move to adopt the

fiance of staffs defiance of council.

>> Click please call the row.

>> Bank Rosa Padilla Dors Remy Ross Vice

President Harden.

>> Adopt it.

>> Thank you. Finally, move passage.

>> Clerk, please call the row.

>> Thanks. Temperos de Padilla Dorance Remy

Ross. Vice President Harden.

>> Passed.

>> All we have tonight in the zoning

committee. Council present.

>> Is there a motion to adjurnn?

>> So move. Second. Cler. Please call the

role.

>> Banks temper roasted deodory Ross. Vice

President Harden.

>> Meeting is adjourned.

Heat

Heat. Heat.

Heat.

Heat.

Heat. Heat.

He's over here.

Heat. Hey, Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Hey.

Hey. Hey.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat.

Heat. Heat. N.

prior to the creation of the purchase

order to wave the competitive bidding

provisions of the Columbus City Code to

authorize the expenditure of $661,500

from the general fund and to declare an

emergency. I move to postpone to the

June 1st, 2026 regular council meeting.

>> Second cler, please call the role.

>> Banks member Rosa deors Remy Ross Vice

President Harden

>> postpone. Next, I have 1377206 to

authorize the appropriation expenditure

of 250,000 within the neighborhood

initiatives sub fund to authorize the

Columbus City Attorney's Office to

extend service contracts with MDDR

Enterprises, Inc. and Lindseay

Automotive, Inc. for vehicle maintenance

and or repair services for the city's

project tail light public safety and

crimerevention program through April

30th, 2027 to authorize the

reimbursement of expenses incurred prior

to the issuance of a purchase order and

to declare an emergency. It is such an

honor to present this ordinance to my

colleagues tonight, which provides

250,000 to continue project taillight.

This is a program that I've supported

for years because of its practical,

effective, and directly tied to the to

the work of public safety and criminal

justice committee. A broken tail light,

worn tires, bad brakes, or another minor

vehicle issue may seem small, but for

many residents, the cost of that repair

can create a real burden. Too often,

families are forced to choose between

fixing the car, paying a bill, buying

groceries, or risking a citation.

Project Taillight helps solve those

problems before they become bigger. It

gets vehicles repaired, keeps drivers,

passengers, and pedestrians safer, and

reduces the need for officers to

initiate avoidable stops um over

equipment violation, and that matters.

So every time we can prevent an

unnecessary traffic stop, we are helping

keep officers available for more serious

calls for service and more urgent public

safety needs across our c um excuse me,

across our neighborhoods. Um we are just

excited to work with the city attorney's

office for them to help um implement

that. Um we're excited that we are

helping, you know, many of these people

that get this assistance are single

mothers

um that wouldn't be able to get their

cars fixed otherwise. That means, you

know, doctor's appointments, that means

work, that means school, all of those

things um are being cured with with this

program. So, we have made the investment

to invest in this work year after year

because it brings so much value to the

residents and to the broader community.

Um, it's this funding also supports

local automotive businesses that are

doing repair work and help deliver the

program directly to residents. So, I

want to thank city attorney Klein, his

team, Vice Chair Ross for her support

and splitting this with me and our

repair partners for helping move the

program forward forward. I could go on

and on, but let me see if you have

anything to say.

In the interest of time, I will not read

all that I have here to say, but I will

say that this um program was born out of

a review of traffic data, which which

basically resulted in um data that

showed us that um a large majority of

folks that are pulled over from

equipment violations have myriad

barriers when it comes to financial

stability in our community. Um, and so I

am proud to support this, not only to

reduce um, contentious experiences

between community and law enforcement

because a lot of those are born from

traffic stops for equipment violations,

but also to ensure that folks are um to

ensure that we are supporting the

reduction of barriers to both

transportation and affordability in our

community. So proud to support this

legislation.

>> Thank you, Council Member Ross. Council

member Rosd.

>> Um, it is such a good program. I love it

so much. Can you also let folks know how

they can find out about it? Like if they

want to use the services, how and where

do they go?

>> You know, um that's a really good

question. I think look up Project

Taillight with the city of Columbus and

you will find um that information on the

website. So I um need to have that

uh let me see if I can do it fast

enough. It's um city attorney. It's

under the city attorney's office, but if

you go ahead and look it up online,

you'll find it right right there. And

the email address is project taillight@c

columbus.gov.

>> Perfect. I just I know that it is um it

is incredibly helpful for folks and um

especially for the folks who need it. I

mean, the same way we talk about

potholes can be detrimental. So can you

know a broken tail light, so can your

brakes, so can all these other things

that folks can't always afford. And so

being able to know how to access those

resources is also just incredibly

important. And thank you for um

continuing to support this program

because we've heard time and time again

stories from folks and how this has been

um so helpful to them and especially

these sorts of blessings always come

along when you need it the most. So

thank you.

>> Thank you so much, council member. Um

are there any other comments or

questions? Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Second call. Banks Timber Rosa Deia Dors

Remy Ross vice president Harden

>> next 1505.26 to authorize and direct the

director of public department of public

safety to modify and extend the contract

with change healthcare technology

enabled services LLC for EM EMS billing

collection and reporting services from

May 31st 2026 to August 31st 2026 to

authorize the expenditure of 350,000

from the general fund to wave the

competitive bidding provision of the

Columbus city codes and to declare an

emergency. Competitive bidding is

requested to be weighed because change

healthcare technology enabled services

is uniquely positioned to complete the

collection of outstanding receivables

that they've already been working on.

Emergency action is necessary to allow

for immediately collection of unpaid

debts. So as the city transitions to a

new EMS billing vendor, there are still

outstanding EMS receivables that need to

be collected and properly closed out.

Change Healthcare is the current

provider, so they are already in

position to continue to do the work

during this short transition. Extension

could mean an increase in revenue for

the city of up to $1.8 million. I also

want to clarify that this expense is

directly tied to collection activity the

vendor is compensated based on revenue

collected and not being paid otherwise.

So, the city is paying for work that

helps recover dollars that may go

uncollected. So, are there any questions

or comments from my colleagues? Seeing

none, I move for passage. Second

>> Bangston Barrosa de Padilla Dorne Remy

Ross Vice President Harden.

>> Thank you very much council president.

That's all I have tonight.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you Mr. Chair. The next committee

to come before council is the housing

homelessness and building committee.

That committee is chaired by ch council

Ross. Council member floor is yours.

>> Thank you council president. Actually

tonight we have three pieces of

important legislation up for a second

read. I will start with ordinance number

1213-2026.

And while I am reading the ordinance

number, I would ask Ambishoff to uh come

to the podium. This is to authorize the

director of the department of

development to enter into a capital

contribution agreement with the

starhouse for facility renovations to

authorize the expenditure in an amount

of of up to $1 million within the

department development taxable bond fund

and to authorize the advancement of

funds on a predetermined schedule. Star

House once operated as a 24-hour drop-in

center and is currently the only drop-in

center for youth ages 14 to 24 who are

experiencing homelessness. At the

drop-in center, youth are provided

immediate access to food, clothing,

hygiene items, laundry facilities,

showers, and a safe place to be, as well

as access therapy, case management,

housing, transportation, healthcare,

employment, education, addiction

services, legal aid, government

benefits, ID cards, and more. In 2025,

Starhouse reported that youth who

visited the drop-in center for 90 days

or more reported the outcomes of secured

critical IDs, enabling them to sign

leases, get jobs, enroll in school,

obtain jobs, disproving myths about

homelessness and unemployment, received

healthc care thanks to on-site partners

like Nationwide Children's and Columbus

Public Health, participated in case

management with our trained clinical

team, chose to engage in therapy, taking

steps to address trauma and PTSD,

obtained housing amidst the nationwide

affordable housing. housing crisis and

this funding will allow renovations to

the second drop-in center on the

southside and renovations of the current

facility in the Milo Groen community.

This investment will ensure that youth

in the community have safe,

well-maintained and adequate place for

reprieve and resource provision during

their stay. Um, thank you to C the CEO

of Starhouse for being here today and

Bishoff will allow you to provide

comment before I move for passage.

>> Thank you and good evening, President

Harden, Sher Ross, council members. I

appreciate the chance to share this

evening. My name is Anne Bishoff, CEO of

Starhouse. I'm here today in support of

ordinance 1213206 to authorize the

director of department the department of

development to enter into a capital

contribution agreement with Starhouse

for facility renovations. For two

decades, Starhouse has partnered with

youth ages 14 to 24 as they exit

homelessness and thrive. Our success has

been made possible by a long-standing

partnership with the city of Columbus

and other key partners. Our Milo Gorgan

drop-in center is the only place in

central Ohio where young people

experiencing homelessness have immediate

year-round access to safety, basic

needs, and stabilizing resources all in

one place. Every day we meet young

people navigating trauma, exploitation,

family rejection, violence, and housing

instability. The environment we provide

matters deeply. Safe, welcoming, and

functional spaces help young people

stabilize, engage in services, and begin

envisioning a different future. Last

school year, we served more than 1,700

individual drop-in center guests, double

the number served four years before

that. After more than a decade of

operating 365 days a year out of the

Milo Groen drop-in center, and with

demand for services growing, the

facility is in urgent need of

renovations and infrastructure

improvements. This proposed investment

would strengthen our ability to serve

youth with dignity, safety, and

effectiveness by supporting essential

facility upgrades. Planned improvements

include the creation of additional

therapy and case management offices and

educational play space for the young

children of our guests, updated HVAC

systems, additional showers and

bathrooms, muchneeded flooring repairs,

parking lot repairs to address flooding

and drainage issues, and other critical

facility enhancements. The impact of our

services prevents chronic homelessness

into adulthood in our community. Among

youth who engaged with Starhouse

services for 90 days or more, an

overwhelming majority obtained housing,

secured employment, accessed medical

services, obtained crucial IDs, and

more. These outcomes are possible

because young people have a stable,

trusted place that serves as a safety

net and a launchpad into stability.

We're grateful to the city of Columbus

for your long-standing partnership and

commitment to young people who are

exiting homelessness. On behalf of the

youth we serve, our staff, our board,

and community partners, thank you for

your consideration, and I respectfully

ask for your support of ordinance 1213

2026. Thank you, and I'm happy to answer

any questions you may have.

>> Thank you, Ann. Any questions or

comments from my colleagues? Council,

>> no, just thank you. Thank you for the

incredible work that you do. I'm so

excited about um the new building on the

south side and the way that you're going

to be able to treat folks. I think you

and I have had conversations about this,

it's just so critical for our young

people um to I think increasingly as we

think about intentional work that we

need to do in communities uh with what

our young people are facing today is so

critical and so Star House has stood in

that gap for a very long time. And so

continuing to develop that work and um

meet be in community and in different

areas of the community so that we can

meet our young people where they are is

just so critical. So thank you.

>> Thank you. Thank you for your support.

>> Thank you Ann. We are certainly excited

about the growth of Starhouse and the

resource that you all continue to

provide to our young people and

community. And so if there are no other

comments or questions for my colleagues,

I'll move for passage. Second

>> banks Denver adorns Remy Ross Vice

President Harden.

>> Thank you, council president. The second

piece of legislation is ordinance number

1368-2026

to authorize the city attorney to enter

into contracts with Columbus Next

Generation Corporation and Habitat for

Humanity Mid Ohio to provide home repair

services under the owner occupied

initiative program to authorize the

reimbursement of qualifying expenses

incurred prior to the creation of the P

purchase orders to authorize the

appropriation and expenditure of funds

within the general fund neighborhood

initiative sub fund and to declare an

emergency. I will talk a little bit

about the owner occupied initiative

program, but we'll ask Tracy uh if you

could come to the podium while I give

some information. The owner occupied

program initiative program is a

collaboration between the city of

Columbus office of the city attorney and

the Franklin County Environmental Courts

to assist homeowners throughout the

city, particularly those who are elderly

and or disabled, in repairing code

violations on their homes. Repair work

has included roof repair and

replacement, gutters, painting, sewer

line work, porch and foundation repair,

removal of dead trees, and remediation

of overgrown vegetation. Council has

extended the program through the end of

this year and authorized Columbus Next

Generation Corporation and Habitat for

Humanity Mid Ohio as partners in

completing the relevant repairs. And

thank you so much to my friend from Next

Generation Corporation for being here.

Um, I will pass it over to you for

remarks before I move for passage.

Thank you so much, Chairman Ross,

Council President Harden, and our

members of council. Thank you for this

opportunity to come before you. Um, most

of you, I know, some of you I've not had

the pleasure of meeting. My name is

Tracy Taylor. Double T for double

trouble, but usually is good trouble.

And I am a graduate of Eastmore.

Yes. So, at the end of 2021,

uh, the city attorney's office, that

client's office noticed increasing code

violations and due to COVID, it kind of

got backed up a little bit more. So,

they need seen a need to try and get

some emergency funding to try and

decrease some of these code violations

and to help our seniors stay in the

homes that they have. Um, Columbus Next

Generation's goal is to redevelop in

urban city neighborhoods, either it be

new developments or repairing some of

the buildings that are there. We also

believe in our mission, and this is my

personal mission, that you cannot build

new buildings and rehab buildings

without addressing the social issues.

And this program does both. It helps

keeps our most vulnerable seniors. And a

lot of those seniors have custody of

their grandchildren in the homes that

they worked for and raised their

families in. Um over the last four and a

half, five years, we have helped over 80

families to stay in their homes. Um they

do have to live in the home and own the

home. Um, we have done repairs from

minor repairs from putting up a porch

railing to gutters to replacing and

repairing roofs to major plumbing um, ex

work for most of the homes. Um, one of

the things that is very personal for me

is almost every homeowner when I do

initial contact with them, they say to

me,

I don't know what to do. I don't want to

lose my home. This is what I worked for.

this is what where I raised my family.

I'm scared. Can you help me? And I think

that this program helps validate that

with our housing crisis. There's nowhere

for them to go. And it also for the

future homeowners, I believe that this

structure of rebuilding these homes

provides for our future homeowners.

I I greatly appreciate and I and I hope

that we have continued support from the

council for this program. I see that it

has had a very valuable

effect on the community not just

financially but socially which I

sometimes is more important than just

the numbers. Um Columbus NextGen has

integrated this program in long terms um

because this is a part of our mission

and we hope to continue to see it grow

and we are blessed to be a part of it.

Thank you for your continued support and

thank you for your time this evening.

Thank you, Tracy. Any comments or

questions from my colleagues?

Um, we certainly appreciate the work of

Next Generation Corporation and also

Habitat for Humanity Mid Ohio. Um, as

someone who used to work in the city

attorney's office and also manage the

owner occupied initiative docket, I too

can attest to um, not only the um,

increase in health outcomes that aging

in place and allowing for aging in place

has on our community, but also it meets

the strategy that we as a city of

Columbus have to promote affordability

in our community by the preservation of

housing stock in our community. And so,

um, I certainly thank you for, uh, being

a partner in this work. It takes several

conversations. It takes lots of

handholding. It takes lots of back and

forth. And it takes a special person to

be able to walk someone through this

process. And so, we appreciate you for

your partnership. Um, your continued

partnership in this program. And so,

that council member doesn't ask me, in

order to receive access to services as a

part of the owner occupied initiative,

you do first have to have a code

violation and there has to be an open

environmental court case. But on that

code violation, there is always a name

and a number right at the bottom. If you

call that name and that number and you

qualify for these resources, you will

get the help. And so instead of ignoring

the code violation, please lean in uh

please call, please ensure that you are

engaging uh with this process so that

you can receive the resources that may

be available to you. Well, and and I

just want to say the last thing I want

to say is I think as people get older,

you know, your your money doesn't go as

far and especially when you're taking

care of other family members. And so

those critical needs, you sometimes

can't even take care of them. And so

this is why this is so important because

it's not just about staying in your home

also means that that roof gets fixed and

that those other issues are addressed.

So I think that's that's the most

important point. And I think that that

this is a gap that we fill because of

that.

>> Agreed. Agreed. Thank you, Tracy.

>> And if there are no com if there are no

other comments or questions, I will move

for passage.

>> Bankston Barrosa de Padilla Dorance Remy

Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Thank you, Council President. And the

final piece of legislation is ordinance

number 1465-2026.

And before I read it, oh, she's already

coming up because she's been here

before. Uh we'd like to welcome

president and CEO of the community

shelter board, Shannon Isum. And this

ordinance is to authorize the director

of the department of development to

enter into a grant agreement with the

community shelter board in an amount up

to $13,75,000

for the purpose of continuing the city's

support for men, women, and families who

are experiencing or at risk of

experiencing homelessness in Columbus.

to authorize the payment of expenses

prior to purchase order execution

starting January 1st, 2026 to authorize

the appropriation and expenditure in an

amount up to $4 million within the

neighborhood partnerships capital fund.

At this time only 3,654,65464

is available and the additional

$345,345.36

will be received near the end of May and

at that time should be appropriated and

an ACPO should be established for use

for this agreement to authorize the

expenditure in an amount up to 13,75,000

to authorize the payment for reasonable

food and non-alcoholic beverages as they

are an integral part of their

operational cost to allow funding to be

advanced to the agency on a

predetermined schedule and to declare an

emergency. This funding will allow CSB

to continue to provide five initiatives

to address homelessness in our

community. The continuum of care

application, crisis response, outreach

services, permanent supportive housing

services, safety net program, and hotel

cost office of violence prevention.

These programs provide support for men,

women, and families who are experiencing

or at risk of experiencing homelessness

in Columbus. CSB leads a coordinated

community effort to make sure everyone

has a place to call home. And with that,

I will pass it to president and CEO of

the Community Shelter Board, Shannon

Ism. Thank you for being at council

today.

>> Absolutely. And thank you. Good evening,

Chair Ross and Vice Chair, uh, Chair

Ross, Vice Chair, and then Council

President Hart and members of the

council. Uh, thank you for your time,

energy, and effort as well towards this.

This is not lost on me that we've asked

for the the largest amount of dollars

from this council, and you said yes. So,

thank you. I know that there are many,

many, many voices uh that made this

possible. Each time that I have the

opportunity to speak about homelessness,

I approach it with the understanding

that many of you many of you understand

the complexities and the challenges that

are before us. Sometimes though it feels

absolutely unrelenting

um and striden and untenable.

Um but homelessness um we know is

persistent at times that um it its need

can feel like it is always outpacing our

resources. This region has refused to

accept that. The council in particular

has refused to accept that. Columbus and

Franklin County have built a strategy, a

system, and a coordinated response that

has been designed to meet these needs.

And the evidence tells us that this

works if we stay the course.

Homelessness is not inevitable. It is

not inevitable.

Um, really quickly, New York's Times

today had an opinion piece that was

entitled Affordable Housing in America.

And the central argument is that the US

housing crisis is fundamentally a

shortage problem.

And as with America,

all of America, it has made far too um

um few housing um development. And it's

we're underbuilding. It's it's hard for

us to keep up. But that under

underbuilding has been for decades and

this underbuilding has pushed ownership

and rent beyond reach for many

households. So um um it talks also about

increased opportunity metro areas.

Franklin County is one of them. We are

struggling with supply.

So we come here, I come here from

community shelter board understanding

that this coordinated system response of

accountability, partnership and shared

responsibility also says that our

progress is predicated on a strong voice

where community alignment is important

in sharing the responsibility but also

that we have to have to be dedicated

that homelessness is rare, brief and

nonrecurring.

And that can only happen if we have more

housing.

Um, so as the federally designated UFA

for Columbus and Franklin County

Community Shelter Boards leads this

funding, this data, this strategy, the

partnership across the coordinated

network for 16 nonprofit agencies to

ensure that our response system remains

responsive and effective and that our

programs are a part of the investment,

but that housing must be the end goal

for the readiness of these partners. The

city's $13 million sustains this core

function of this system. Um,

Councilwoman Ross, you mentioned it.

Prevention, diversion, emergency

shelter, outreach, pathways to housing

stability is the key. Housing stability.

We must um ensure that we are focused on

housing. So, while we continue to make

progress, these headwinds are growing.

Um many of you know I won't um sit down

before taking the opportunity that the

point in time count showed us a couple

of things that um homelessness is

increasing

um that nonsheltered homelessness saw a

43% increase over the previous year and

we know that this will continue to

increase. Why do we know this? We

predictive modeling told us so.

And so, uh, these dollars that will be

put, every dollar will be put on the

ground for homelessness and housing.

Um, but, um, my voice if before I sit

down, um, would be remiss if I don't say

that the work that we continue and the

investment

um, is um, more than just shelter beds,

but it must be to protect the readiness

of our system. So, on behalf of the

community shelter board, our system

partners, uh, we ask for your support

for the ordinance. Thank you, um,

Councilwoman Ross, for bringing this

forward. And we thank council, we thank

Mayor Gther, Director Michael Stevens,

and the Department of Development for

your continued leadership and making

homelessness rare and brief, helping us

to make it non-recurring across our

region. Thank you for your time, and I'm

happy to answer any questions and along

with this ordinance. Thank you,

President Isim. Uh, any questions or

comments for President Isim from my

colleagues?

Well, we certainly thank you for all of

the work that you continue to do. It's

not easy work. It is hard work. And um,

we appreciate all of the partners who

you support in this work and um, I'm

going to allow my chair or vice chair to

make comment if he would like to. Okay.

Awesome. Well, this is the best package

of legislation I think I've passed to

date. Um, so I'm very excited. If there

are no if there are no other comments or

questions from my colleagues, I'll move

for passage.

>> Please call the

>> Bangston Barrosa Deodia adorns Remy Ross

w president Harden

>> passed.

>> That is it for me. Thank you.

>> Thank you, madam chair. Good work

tonight. Uh, the final committee coming

for council is the public utilities and

sustainability committee chair by

council wel is yours.

>> Thank you council president. We were so

close everyone to not going last. We'll

try again next week. Um, first I have

ordinance 882-2026

to authorize the director of public

utilities to enter into a construction

contract with Kakosing Industrial

Incorporated for the Parsons Avenue

Wellfield Development Project to

authorize an amendment to the 2025

capital improvement budget to

appropriate funds within the water

freshwater market rate fund to make this

ordinance contingent upon the Ohio Water

Development Authority approving a loan

for this project to authorize the

expenditure of up to $33,85,400

from the Waterfresh water market rate

fund to pay for the project and to

authorize the expenditure of up to

$2,000 from the water bond fund to pay

for prevailing wage services. This

project involves the construction of a

seventh radial uh collector well at the

Parson's Avenue Water Plant, helping to

offset the anticipated future loss of

other collector wells. This work will

ensure that the Parson's Avenue Water

Plant is able to continue treating and

supplying safe drinking water to

Columbus and other surrounding

communities. Let me stop there, see if

any questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Thanks, Tim. Rosa de Padilla, Dors,

Remy, Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Pass. Thank you. Next, I have 105-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Public Utilities to modify

and increase the contract with Burgess

and Knipel Incorporated for the Jackson

Pike Water Reclamation Plant Screening

Improvements Project. to authorize the

appropriation and transfer of funds from

the sanitary sewer reserve fund to the

water pollution control loan fund. To

authorize the appropriation of funds

within the sanitary revolving loan fund

to authorize an expenditure of up to

2,380,53

from the water pollution control loan

fund to pay for the project and to

declare an emergency. This project

involves improvements to two aging

mechanical screens at the Jackson Pike

water reclamation plant. These screens

are necessary for removing large debris

from the waste water that enters the

plant. Emergency designation is

requested as the existing screens cannot

adequately remove debris and could

therefore cause damage or extra repair

expense in the future. Let me stop there

and see if any questions or comments

from my colleagues. Seeing none, I move

for passage.

>> Please call the role.

>> Banks temper rosa deodia dorance reie

Ross vice president Harden

>> pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1058-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Public Utilities to enter

into a professional engineering services

contract with Glass, Pike, Schumer,

Burns, and De Haven Incorporated for the

Division of Water Reclamation Sanitary

Pump Stations Construction Project to

authorize an amendment to the 2025

capital improvement budget to authorize

the appropriation of funds within the

Sanitary Revolving Loan Fund to

authorize this contract to be funded

with a loan from the Water Pollution

Control Loan Fund to make this ordinance

contingent upon the Ohio Water

Development Authority. approving a loan

for this project and to authorize the

expenditure of up to $2,58,861.31

from the sanitary revolving loan fund

for the contract. This ordinance

involves a variety of improvements to

the division of water reclamation

sanitary pump stations which are

essentially to uh which are essential to

the collection of wastewater. These

improvements will ensure that the pump

stations have the capacity to keep up

with demand and maintain peak

operational performance. Let me stop

there. See if any questions or comments

from my colleagues. Seeing none, I move

for passage.

>> Cler, please call the role.

>> Thanks. Denver Rosa de Padilla Dors Remy

Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Passed.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1117-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Technology on behalf of

Columbus Water and Power to enter into a

contract with Realtime Networks

Incorporated for hosting an ongoing

support of an electric key management

system to wave the competitive bidding

provisions of chapter 329 of Columbus

City codes and to authorize expenditure

of $80,16

from the Department of Technology

Information Services Division

Information Services Operating Fund.

This ordinance provides the funding for

the maintenance and ongoing support of

Columbus Water and Power's electronic

key system which enhances the security

of the department's facilities,

vehicles, and other assets. Let me stop

there, see if any questions or comments

from my colleagues. Seeing none, I move

for passage.

Cl

>> Bankston Barosa Deadia Dorren Remy Ross,

Vice President Harden.

>> Pass. Thank you. Next, I have 1133-2026.

to authorize the director of public

utilities to enter into a construction

contract with the lead excavating

company of Ohio incorporated for the

Youngs Drive Area Waterline Improvements

Project to amend the 2025 capital

improvement budget to authorize the

director of public utilities to apply

for and accept a loan from the Ohio

Water Development Authority Direct Loan

Program for the Young's Drive Area Water

Line Improvements Project to appropriate

funds within the Waterfresh Water Market

Rate Fund to authorize an expenditure of

up to 7,478 $8,897.80

from the water market rate fund for the

contract to make this ordinance

contingent upon the Ohio Water

Development Authority approving a loan

for the project and to authorize the

expenditure of up to $2,000 from the

water bond fund to pay for prevailing

wage services. This project consists of

the installation of approximately 10,575

linear feet of new water manes as well

as the replacement of privatelyowned

lead and galvanized water service lines

in the Northland community. This project

will improve water service, reduce

burden on water maintenance operations,

and minimize water loss. Let me stop

there. See if any questions or comments

from my colleagues. Seeing none, I move

for passage. Second,

>> please call the role.

>> Banks. Timber adorns Remy Ross, Vice

President Harden.

>> Pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1142-2026

to authorize the director of public

utilities to enter into a construction

contract with complete general

construction company for the community

park Maple Canyon Home Sewage Treatment

System Elimination Project to authorize

an amendment to the 2025 capital

improvement budget to appropriate funds

within the water pollution control load

fund to authorize a transfer of cash and

appropriation between projects within

the sanitary bond fund to make this

ordinance contingent upon the Ohio Water

Development Authority approving a loan

for this project and to authorize the

expenditure up to 2,152,551.20

from the water pollution control loan

fund and the storm bond fund to pay for

the project. This project consists of

the installation of approximately 2200

linear feet of sanitary sewer mains as

well as other improvements to existing

storm infrastructure in the Northland

community. This work will mitigate

drainage and flooding issues and prevent

sanitary sewer overflows to basement and

waterways. Let me stop there. See if any

questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Clerk, please call the role.

>> Banks temper roa deodorie Ross, vice

president Harden.

>> Passed.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1164-2026

to authorize and direct the city auditor

to appropriate and transfer funds from

the special purpose POS settlement fund

to Columbus Water and Power Water

Operating Fund. In July 2025, the city

authorized uh the city was authorized to

accept settlement claims in a product

liability case. This ordinance

authorizes transfer of these funds so

that they can be used by the division of

water for the purpose of improving water

quality. Let me stop there. See if any

questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Clerk, please call the role.

>> Thanks. Timber adors Remy Ross, Vice

President Harden.

>> Pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have ordinance

1206-2026

to authorize the director of public

utilities to modify the service contract

with Senegro Central LLC for the Parsons

Avenue water plant residuals removal and

disposal Lagoon 3 project and to

authorize the expenditure of up to $12

million from the water operating fund.

This project involves the removal and

disposal of residual waste materials

collected during the water purification

process. This work will preserve the

existing lagoon, allowing it to continue

being used for residual storage and

avoiding more uh other more costly

solutions. Let me stop there. See if any

questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Please call the role.

>> Banks tempos deodorie Ross vice

president Harden

>> pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1215-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Public Utilities to enter

into a construction contract with JLD

Construction Services LLC for the lead

service line replacements part three

project to amend the 2025 capital

improvement budget to authorize a

transfer of cash appropriation between

the water system reserve fund and the

water supply revolving loan account fund

to authorize the appropriation and

expenditure of up to 10,756,912

from the water supply revolving loan

account fund for the contract to

authorize the expendure of up to 2,000

$2,000 from the water bond fund to pay

for prevailing wage services and to

declare an emergency. Uh this ordinance

funds the replacement of lead water

service lines in the greater hilltop

community, an estimated 548 public side

and 274 private side service lines will

be replaced. Let me stop there. See if

any questions or comments for my

colleagues.

Seeing none, I move for passage.

>> Clerk, please call the role.

>> Banks deormy Ross, vice president

Harden.

>> Pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have ordinance

1223-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Finance and Management to

enter into a contract with uh Peterson

Highway Safety Incorporated for the

purchase and delivery of 20 solar

powered trailer mounted arrow boards for

the Department of Public Utilities to

wave competitive bidding provisions of

chapter 329 of Columbus City Code and to

authorize expenditure of $93,800

from the water operating fund. These

arrow boards will be used by maintenance

supervisors and barricade crews to

direct the flow of traffic in the event

of road closures. Therefore, creating a

safe parking area for crews to fix water

main breaks. Let me stop there. See if

any questions or comments from my

colleagues.

Seeing none, I move for passage.

>> Clerk, please call the ro.

>> Thanks, Tim. Peros dors Remy Ross, Vice

President Harden.

>> Pass.

>> Thank you. Next, I have 1254-2026

to authorize the director of the

Department of Public Utilities to modify

the contract with J&D Home Improvement

LLC doing business as the basement

doctor for the blueprint volunteer sump

pump 2025B project to authorize an

amendment to the 2025 capital

improvement budget to transfer cash and

appropriation between projects within

the sanitary bond fund and to authorize

an expenditure of $1 million from the

sanitary bond fund to pay for the

contract modification. As one of the

main pillars of the blueprint process,

this project consists of residents

volunteering for the installation of

some pumps in their homes. This will

reduce excess uh storm water entering

the city sanitary sewer system, thus

minimizing sewer overflows to basements

and waterways. Let me stop there. See if

any questions or comments from my

colleagues. Seeing none, I move for

passage.

>> Please call the role.

>> Banks temporarosa deors remy ros vice

president Harden

>> passed. Thank you. And last, I have

ordinance uh 1389-2026

to authorize and direct the director of

the Department of Public Service,

sorry, to enter into a contract with

NextStar Broadcasting Incorporated doing

business as WCMH for marketing campaign

services for the Cleaner Columbus

Initiative, to authorize an

appropriation and expenditure within the

neighborhood initiative sub fund to wave

the competitive bidding requirements of

Columbus City Code, and to declare an

emergency.

I will kick things over to my vice

chair, council member Remy, to speak to

this last ordinance in the committee.

>> Thank you very much, Council Member W.

Uh, this is an ordinance that I've been

proud to found and it's an ongoing

initiative for my office. Cleaner

Columbus has made a real positive change

in the community over the years. This

ordinance allows our annual contract

with NBC4 to continue marketing and

creating public awareness for support

for the Cleaner Columbus initiative.

Cleaner Columbus starts be started

because residents told us clearly that

litter in our streets, alleys, and

neighborhoods affects their quality of

life and pride in where they live. This

partnership with NBC4 helps us reach

more residents, promote sustainability,

and make sure people know and about

future opportunities to get involved,

provides jobs and opportunities to earn

money for nonprofits to those that help

with our cleanup eupf efforts across the

city. So, we saw exactly how that worked

last week with our fifth annual citywide

cleanup where we had more than 300

volunteers and and collected almost

10,000 lbs of litter. So, thank you,

Council Member White. Appreciate the

opportunity to share. Have a great

>> No worries, Vice Chair. And with that, I

move for passage.

>> Please call the role.

>> Thanks. Timber Rosa Padilla Dors Remy

Ross, Vice President Harden.

>> Passed.

>> Thank you. That is all I have for mine

committee this evening.

>> Thank you, Mr. Chair see no further

business come for council. Is there a

motion to adjurnn? Click please call the

role.

>> Banks timber roia dors rece.

We have three nine agendas.