Delaware County (OH) Board of Commissioners · 2026-05-04

Transcript

Delaware County Commissioners' Session- May 4, 2026a

615 segments

May 4th, 2026 meeting of the Delaware

County Board of Commissioners. It is now

1:30.

And our

business right now will be the viewing

of the

The what?

Yeah, Bainbridge Mills phase one

subdivision drainage improvement

petition.

And um

I'll introduce Mr. Merrell and

Commissioner Benton.

Commissioner Lewis is absent today

and I'll go through what we're going to

do today.

Um and again, this is just the viewing.

So, I want to welcome everyone to to

this viewing.

Uh there's a sign-in sheet circulating

the room. We ask you please sign the

sheet to indicate your attendance.

And today's viewing of the proposed

improvement area is taking place here

um with the use of video technology,

which has been a really nice improvement

for us. A video [snorts] will be

available to gain an overview of the

project limits and specific areas.

No testimony or decisions are made here

at the viewing. That's important. We

don't take testimonies whether you

should do this or shouldn't do it. We're

just here to observe the

the

the drainage or the drainage area.

Um

and it's a way for us to become familiar

with the with the area.

The first hearing on the petition is

scheduled for Monday, August 3rd, 2026

at 10:00 a.m. here again. At the

hearing, we'll hear a report from the

engineer's office on the petition. And

that is also the time for landowner

testimony for or against the petition.

Uh when it's time for landowners to

point out the drainage concerns of the

area, we will work our way through the

participants.

As a [snorts] reminder, this is not not

the time for testimony.

I will now turn the proceeding over to

Brett Bacon from the Soil and Water

Conservation District.

Good afternoon, Commissioners. Brett

Bacon, Deputy Administrator, Soil and

Water.

Um

so, you have two maps or two two pieces

of paper. One is just the

map of the subdivision showing the

boundary of phase one of Bainbridge

Mills.

I will note that phase two is already on

drainage maintenance by virtue of when

it was platted. It was platted after

July 1st of '98. Phase one was prior to

that. So, phase one missed the

enactment of that requirement through

the platting regulations.

The other thing

>> Just two phases, Brad? Pardon? Are there

just two phases?

>> Yes.

This other sheet is taken from the

engineering plans for phase one. I

thought it would be useful to highlight

the location of the storm water

infrastructure

just because yes, we're going to apply a

drone video, but all the infrastructure

here save for the two detention basins

is underground. So, you really can't see

much.

But, this shows you where the

infrastructure that we would initially

at least propose to take under

maintenance is located. I will point out

that the location of the two detention

basins, they're dry basins, as we it

flies near them.

But, I will show the video and then be

happy to answer any questions the board

may have. Okay.

So, this is starting

on your on your subdivision map on the

west side along Sawmill Road as it turns

into Bainbridge Mills Drive.

First detention basin is located right

here.

This is Robstone Court.

Second detention basin is located here.

This is Sable Court.

And then right here is the phase

boundary

between phase one and phase two.

And this is phase two already on

maintenance.

Okay.

That's that's pretty short viewing.

Pretty short. Pretty small area. Yes.

Yes.

Um

Mr. Mayor, any questions at this point?

>> no questions at the moment. I just had a

maybe one or a couple of others. Um

When when was the the drainage

the improvements of division developer

product plotted and the drainage

improvements made, do you know? I will

let you know that at the first hearing.

Okay. So you don't

>> I have not done that level of research

yet. So at this point, again, you don't

know of any needed improvements. There

could be. You'll conduct your research.

>> I'm I'm not anticipating any anything

out of the normal. Um my expectation

would be this will be

kind of our our typical uh you know,

pre-1998 subdivision asking to go on to

maintenance. Have seen nothing that

would indicate otherwise. Uh we'll

certainly

um

you know, take a walk. Uh we won't do

any detailed investigation until after

the first hearing, but we'll we'll

certainly take a walk around the

neighborhood

uh prior to the first hearing in an

effort to um you know, compile that

first hearing report. And certainly

we'll have the you know, the research on

when when [clears throat] the

subdivision was plotted and constructed

and you know, that that typical info

that we provide to you. Okay.

Uh okay.

Uh nothing further for breath at this

point. We will

open it up to anyone who wants to point

out something about the infrastructure,

you know, that that is a problem or

potential problem or

you know, again, not not getting into

whether you favor it or oppose it, but

just saying here's here's a concern or

here's you know, you know, some

observation.

Yeah. Is based on the three And

[clears throat] I'm sorry, we'll ask you

to come up to the microphone cuz we're

we're recording this.

Sorry, does that Does that make you

nervous, we A little bit.

Um my name is Stacy Larson. I'm a

trustee on the Bainbridge Island board.

>> Okay. Um we do have a basin three that's

in phase two. I'm just You You know, I'm

sorry, you have what? It's a It's

another basin Basin three?

>> In phase two?

>> portion of phase [clears throat] two. I

just want to confirm, is it already

covered under phase two, or is that

something that will be covered under

this My understanding is yes, but I'll

have Brent uh confirm that.

Yes, if it's in phase two, it should

already be covered by drainage

maintenance. Um but if [clears throat]

it's not, then we would look, you know,

to include that.

Okay.

Good. Pretty good turnout today. Anybody

have any Anything again they'd like to

point out about the

drainage um situation there? Come on up

to the microphone. Again, we're

recording it, so we we ask you to come

on up to the microphone.

You can just let identify yourself.

>> is Julia Sayne. I'm a resident in

Bainbridge Mills. I have two questions.

One is, it sounds like there was no

particular incident that triggered this

potential project. Is that right?

Yeah, Brett, you want to answer that?

>> of those questions now. Oh, okay.

Uh the other one is, based on the

investigation, this project may or may

not happen. Is that right?

Brett's had those questions many times.

So, I I'm not going to speak to why the

petition was filed. Um

I think that that's a question better

asked to

um Ms. Larson and and those that filed

the petition as to what their reasons

were. The The petition is to consider

including the infrastructure on drainage

maintenance, and that's what we're going

to to uh proceed under if the board

approves us in August. 15 people maybe

that signed the petition.

So. Yeah.

Second question, I'll speak to

procedure.

We will compile a report for the first

hearing.

That report will be presented to the

Board of Commissioners. The

Commissioners will take testimony. After

the conclusion of the hearing, the

Commissioners will vote to proceed with

the petition or not. If they vote to

proceed at that point, that will

authorize us to move into that

investigation phase where we will take a

more detailed

thorough look at the stormwater system

and assess its its current condition. We

will return a report along with any cost

recommendations back to the County

Commissioners. At that time, they will

schedule a final hearing on the project

where they will again take testimony

from the

any any resident within the subdivision

that wishes to testify, and then the

board would make a decision as to

whether to accept the the system onto

drainage maintenance or not.

Yeah, this is new to most people. Most

people who don't know about, you know,

this legislation and this ditch

maintenance program. So,

inevitably there's going to be a lot of

questions. I'll I'll make this

statement. I don't think I'll cross any

boundaries, but

I think a lot of people look at this

kind of like an insurance policy. Going

forward, you don't have to worry about

the drainage. You know it's going to be

taken care of and it removes that

concern going forward. And I think a lot

of people look at it in that respect and

we're following the guidelines from the

state on how to handle these and Soil

and Water does an excellent job in

providing the

background research before we have our

first hearing. And what are there about

600 and some

ditches,

watersheds in the in the maintenance

program?

>> We've actually crested 670 now. If we

counted all the

original subdivisions still as a as a

single project, we would be over 670

drainage maintenance projects. Anywhere

from agricultural true agricultural

ditches to rural residential projects

and sub single family subdivisions and

condos and commercial projects. So

>> Yeah.

Um and Commissioner Merrill's

description is very accurate. That's

what we exactly what we refer to

drainage maintenance as. It is a form of

insurance

uh and

uh when a system does go on to drainage

maintenance, in effect, what it does is

elevate the drainage system to a quasi

public utility. So

Yeah.

And again, I would I would uh vouch for

the I would vouch for the the group as

well. They they do an excellent job of

taking care of the 670

uh ditches that they maintain. But I I

would add these the things are not 100%.

We have turned down some. The purpose of

this process is to determine whether it

makes sense for this neighborhood and

the testimony will be extremely

important in making that decision at the

first hearing whether go to the second

hearing or not. So

uh and there have been some turned down.

So it's not an automatic.

Uh you and the neighborhood and your

testimony will have a lot to say about

what the direction we travel, right?

Those are the criteria we look at. Is is

it worth the cost? You know, does it

help the neighborhood and so on.

Um

so yeah, Brett, another comment? Yeah,

we had this question come up in

discussion um

before the viewing and I think it's just

maybe important to state it again. Uh

when we compile the first hearing

report, that's going to contain a very

basic cost estimate. Um

it'll it'll contain an estimate as to

whether we think at that point there

might need to be work required and and

also an estimate of the you know, the

annual maintenance cost. When we get to

the final hearing, if we move to that

step, we would have a very detailed uh

cost estimate for for each parcel in the

subdivision and parcels would know

exactly what their

any proposed cost might be or their

annual maintenance cost estimates as

well. Right.

>> [clears throat]

>> So any other comments? Oh, we got

another comment. Sure, come on up.

>> Okay, Kate Larson again.

Um,

it was brought to our attention last

summer and that phase two was already

under some maintenance program. So,

that's what that's what kind of spiked

it to everybody to understand where

where are we at as far as phase one? I'm

obviously phase one. And the concern

was brought up that we don't understand

how those things are maintained and how

they get fixed in the phase one area.

So, having some on my property myself,

the concern is

how does that cost come into play? Is it

everybody in phase one? Is it up to the

individual homeowner? And I have no idea

what type of cost we're talking about,

whether it's a sewer drain or a pipe

breakage or flooding of areas. And so,

[clears throat] we started

investigating, reached out to Brett. He

explained quite a bit of it.

Um,

but I've been there 26 years, so in the

last 26 years we've, you know, our

HOA has primarily been maintenancing and

taking care of all the inlets, outlets

and the three basins

that we mentioned earlier. So, we've

we've absorbed that. We've removed

trees. We've taken care of things the

best we know how. I'm not aware of any

um, like breakage or primary things that

have been brought to our attention,

um,

anything different than levitation of

like, uh,

elevation of somebody's property, but

other than that, we are not aware of

anything yet. That's what we're hoping

to find out through him. But that's how

this came about. So, it was it was

suggested that once they got their

Delaware County,

um, thing on board that we would

try to get phase two into or phase one

into something like phase one, so that

we're kind of all on an even playing

field and that anything we would incur

in the future that we would be able to

handle it and understand how that's

taken care of. There is just one HOA for

both phases, right? Correct. Yes.

We do have a couple signatures on the

petition from phase two in support cuz

they understand the concern that we

have. They're already paying that

through their property tax, so we want

to

basically be grandfathered in or brought

into that same type of maintenance

program. So,

I still don't understand how it works,

what your findings are, if it's

individual homeowner or is it up to the

HOA or is it

do we

the whole phase one? That that is a

concern based on whatever findings you

have.

It It would be assessed to each

individual homeowner, each parcel owner.

If the HOA owns a parcel, they would

receive an assessment. Okay. If If

again, if there's a cost. There

isn't always a cost.

>> Cuz a lot of these look like they're in

an easement.

Yeah, if

um

if we would proceed for for maintenance,

um the subdivision would be brought into

the subdivision drainage maintenance

district and each property would be

assessed uh as a 0.3 mills assessment

against the taxable value of the

property. If we identified any

construction that was necessary, we

would estimate the cost of that

construction and then that would be

proposed to be split equally among the

properties within phase one. So, I I

think that Hope that answers the

question. Yeah, there's two really two

potential charges. One is for

construction, fixing, you know, it to

county standards. Second is then the on

ongoing maintenance.

So, there's potentially two separate

charges. Yes, sir, you had a You had a

comment as well.

Come on up.

Name is Evan Byerley. We're at 10707

Sable Court, which is in the back.

Um just looking at the map, I noticed

there's no There's no drainage behind

the properties like on the county line.

Is there anything proposed or would the

assessment take into account, you know,

some of we do have some some ponding in

in some potential water issues back

there, um but is this an opportunity to

assess that and assess additional

cost for those types of projects as

well?

Brett, you want to cover that?

So, the petition was to

include the stormwater per the original

engineering plans.

Um

I would be happy to meet with those

individual lot owners and and assess

whether there's something that can be

done to address their concerns, but I

don't think it would be part of this

petition.

So,

at least initially that's what I'm going

to say.

Good.

All right, any other

questions, comments? Yep, come on up.

Hi.

Uh Jamie Byerly, also Sable Court. Um I

think may and this might be putting the

cart before the horse, but let's say

this does go through all the approval

processes. I think for us to go back

into our neighborhood today and they ask

what what happened at the meeting, I

think it'd be really helpful for us to

maybe just give a brief description of

what the construction would actually

look like once that happens. I think

that would be helpful to know, um what

kind of

damage to the yards, things of that

nature [clears throat] would be helpful

to know. I think I know the answer

you're going to get from Brett is we

don't know.

>> Okay, gotcha. Gotcha. That's accurate.

And that's I thought it might be putting

the

when you come back and assess, that'll

give us more

>> That's accurate, Brett. [clears throat]

We don't know at this point just cuz he

hadn't he hadn't done the inspection. He

he he just doesn't Sure. Sure. We're

just at the first phase.

I I'll answer it as I hope there's

nothing. Yeah.

You know, your hope is you go out here

and find that the system is is good and

doesn't require repair. But but to

answer

you know, what the scope of that may

look like before we've we've done any

kind of survey or investigation is just

not possible.

Can you maybe

the first phase that is in the drainage

Could you What's the history? What What

did you find when you did that? Do you

recall?

Um I'm sorry, Commissioner Marrow. I

can't answer that because I've just not

I don't I

I don't think we've had to do extensive

work in Bainbridge Mills.

Um it's not

it's not an account that

pops out to me as one that I've I've had

to account for spending a lot of money

out there. So um I think it's just been

routine maintenance. And typically what

we will find um

on these older projects as far as work

that might need done. Um

a lot of times

there might be some degradation of the

concrete around the catch basins,

manholes, things like that that might

need need work.

Um

You might have a a

manhole that's been covered by

landscaping or or um you know, is not

physically visible that we've got to put

a riser on and and bring it up so that

we can access it. And and then honestly

one of the biggest things that we see on

the older subdivisions is an

accumulation of grit or just debris in

the storm drain itself. Something that's

very easily taken care of with a a

They call it a jet. It's a specialized

company that we would bring in that will

wash that out and flush it out

basically. But that's that'd be your I

guess your typical things and those

would not be items that we would look to

do as a construction assessment. It It

would be taken care of under drainage

maintenance. When we think of uh

you know, work that we might have to do,

um

one, your board just recently considered

one where there was a

just a multitude of trees that had been

permitted to grow up over the storm line

and we had to propose taking those trees

down. I don't think that's the case

here. The you know, just looking at the

drone video, there's not anything that

prevents accessing the infrastructure.

Um if we put our tile camera in and and

notice some imminent failure in a

section, we might have to

um take care of that depending on the

size of the pipe, but um I just

I mean, I don't want to speak out of

turn without, you know, having even done

the first hearing report here, but

nothing jumps out at me in this

subdivision that that throws up red

flags right now, so.

Okay. Yeah, and we just had one that

somebody had built a pool over the

over the Oh my goodness. over the

drainage pipe. Oh wow.

You know, I think we forget sometimes,

we see a lot of these.

This is your first one.

And so, your questions are reasonable.

>> They're very good questions. Um but

they're questions that find a way to be

responded to and answered and either

reassure you or raise concerns based on

your perspective. And that'll that'll

become clearer in the first hearing and

then a decision will be made whether we

go to a second hearing or not. But

again, we sometimes forget that

this is unique for you. This is fairly

typical for us because we see them we

see a lot of them. You just heard the

number.

Now, I haven't been here for all 670 of

them.

Uh but I've been here for a lot of them.

And so, uh just I just trust the

process. Yeah.

Um okay. Any other comments, questions?

Again, Brett is a wealth of knowledge.

Brett Burford's in the back in the

engineer's office, he's great, too. You

know, feel free to reach out to them.

They're happy to, you know, sit down and

answer questions cuz again, this as

Sheryl said, this is very different for

most people. So.

Okay.

So, Jennifer, nothing else? No, we can

do it.

>> adjourned.